Protection from pathogenic SIV challenge using multigenic DNA vaccines

Nancy Haigwood, Christopher C. Pierce, Michael N. Robertson, Andrew J. Watson, David C. Montefiori, Michael Rabin, John B. Lynch, LaRene Kuller, Jannelle Thompson, William R. Morton, Raoul E. Benveniste, Shiu Lok Hu, Philip Greenberg, Sally P. Mossman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

46 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

To assess DNA immunization as a strategy for protecting against HIV infection in humans, we utilized SIVmne infection of Macaca fascicularis as a vaccine challenge model with moderate pathogenic potential. We compared the efficacy of DNA immunization alone and in combination with subunit protein boosts. All of the structural and regulatory genes of SIVmne clone 8 were cloned into mammalian expression vectors under the control of the CMV IE-1 promoter. Eight M. fascicularis were immunized twice with 3 mg of plasmid DNA divided between two sites; intramuscular and intradermal. Four primed macaques received a further two DNA immunizations at weeks 16-36, while the second group of four were boosted with 250 μg recombinant gp160 plus 250 μg recombinant Gag-Pol particles formulated in MF-59 adjuvant. Half of the controls received four immunizations of vector DNA; half received two vector DNA and two adjuvant immunizations. As expected, humoral immune responses were stronger in the macaques receiving subunit boosts, but responses were sustained in both groups. Significant neutralizing antibody titers to SIVmne were detected in one of the subunit-boosted animals and in none of the DNA- only animals prior to challenge. T-cell proliferative responses to gp160 and to Gag were detected in all immunized animals after three immunizations, anti these responses increased after four immunizations. Cytokine profiles in PHA- stimulated PBMC taken on the day of challenge showed trends toward Th1 responses in 2,4 macaques in the DNA vaccinated group and in 1/4 of the DNA plus subunit vaccinated macaques: Th2 responses in 3/4 DNA plus subunit- immunized macaques; and Th0 responses in 4/4 controls. In bulk CTL culture, SIV specific lysis was low or undetectable, even after four immunizations. However, stable SIV Gag Poland env-specific T-cell clones (CD3+ CD8+) were isolated after only two DNA immunizations, and Gag Pol- and Nef-specific CTL lines were isolated on the day of challenge. All animals were challenged at week 38 with SIVmne uncloned stock by the intrarectal route. Based on antibody anamnestic responses (western, ELISA, and neutralizing antibodies) and virus detection methods (co-culture of PBMC and LNMC, nested set PCR- of DNA from PBMC and LNMC, and plasma QC-PCR), there were major differences between the groups in the challenge outcome. Surprisingly, sustained low virus loads were observed only in the DNA group, suggesting that four immunizations with DNA only elicited more effective immune responses than two DNA primes combined with two protein boosts. Multigenic DNA vaccines such as these, bearing all structural and regulatory genes, show significant promise and may be a safe alternative to live-attenuated vaccines.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)183-188
Number of pages6
JournalImmunology Letters
Volume66
Issue number1-3
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 1999
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

DNA Vaccines
Immunization
DNA
Macaca
Macaca fascicularis
Regulator Genes
Neutralizing Antibodies
Clone Cells
Viruses
T-Lymphocytes
Polymerase Chain Reaction
Attenuated Vaccines
Protein Subunits
Poland
Humoral Immunity
Coculture Techniques

Keywords

  • Antibody
  • CTL
  • Cytokine
  • Genetic immunization
  • HIV-1
  • SIV
  • Vaccines

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Immunology
  • Immunology and Allergy

Cite this

Haigwood, N., Pierce, C. C., Robertson, M. N., Watson, A. J., Montefiori, D. C., Rabin, M., ... Mossman, S. P. (1999). Protection from pathogenic SIV challenge using multigenic DNA vaccines. Immunology Letters, 66(1-3), 183-188. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0165-2478(98)00156-4

Protection from pathogenic SIV challenge using multigenic DNA vaccines. / Haigwood, Nancy; Pierce, Christopher C.; Robertson, Michael N.; Watson, Andrew J.; Montefiori, David C.; Rabin, Michael; Lynch, John B.; Kuller, LaRene; Thompson, Jannelle; Morton, William R.; Benveniste, Raoul E.; Hu, Shiu Lok; Greenberg, Philip; Mossman, Sally P.

In: Immunology Letters, Vol. 66, No. 1-3, 01.03.1999, p. 183-188.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Haigwood, N, Pierce, CC, Robertson, MN, Watson, AJ, Montefiori, DC, Rabin, M, Lynch, JB, Kuller, L, Thompson, J, Morton, WR, Benveniste, RE, Hu, SL, Greenberg, P & Mossman, SP 1999, 'Protection from pathogenic SIV challenge using multigenic DNA vaccines', Immunology Letters, vol. 66, no. 1-3, pp. 183-188. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0165-2478(98)00156-4
Haigwood N, Pierce CC, Robertson MN, Watson AJ, Montefiori DC, Rabin M et al. Protection from pathogenic SIV challenge using multigenic DNA vaccines. Immunology Letters. 1999 Mar 1;66(1-3):183-188. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0165-2478(98)00156-4
Haigwood, Nancy ; Pierce, Christopher C. ; Robertson, Michael N. ; Watson, Andrew J. ; Montefiori, David C. ; Rabin, Michael ; Lynch, John B. ; Kuller, LaRene ; Thompson, Jannelle ; Morton, William R. ; Benveniste, Raoul E. ; Hu, Shiu Lok ; Greenberg, Philip ; Mossman, Sally P. / Protection from pathogenic SIV challenge using multigenic DNA vaccines. In: Immunology Letters. 1999 ; Vol. 66, No. 1-3. pp. 183-188.
@article{8f833d1866284fd1ae171c3c41ae5761,
title = "Protection from pathogenic SIV challenge using multigenic DNA vaccines",
abstract = "To assess DNA immunization as a strategy for protecting against HIV infection in humans, we utilized SIVmne infection of Macaca fascicularis as a vaccine challenge model with moderate pathogenic potential. We compared the efficacy of DNA immunization alone and in combination with subunit protein boosts. All of the structural and regulatory genes of SIVmne clone 8 were cloned into mammalian expression vectors under the control of the CMV IE-1 promoter. Eight M. fascicularis were immunized twice with 3 mg of plasmid DNA divided between two sites; intramuscular and intradermal. Four primed macaques received a further two DNA immunizations at weeks 16-36, while the second group of four were boosted with 250 μg recombinant gp160 plus 250 μg recombinant Gag-Pol particles formulated in MF-59 adjuvant. Half of the controls received four immunizations of vector DNA; half received two vector DNA and two adjuvant immunizations. As expected, humoral immune responses were stronger in the macaques receiving subunit boosts, but responses were sustained in both groups. Significant neutralizing antibody titers to SIVmne were detected in one of the subunit-boosted animals and in none of the DNA- only animals prior to challenge. T-cell proliferative responses to gp160 and to Gag were detected in all immunized animals after three immunizations, anti these responses increased after four immunizations. Cytokine profiles in PHA- stimulated PBMC taken on the day of challenge showed trends toward Th1 responses in 2,4 macaques in the DNA vaccinated group and in 1/4 of the DNA plus subunit vaccinated macaques: Th2 responses in 3/4 DNA plus subunit- immunized macaques; and Th0 responses in 4/4 controls. In bulk CTL culture, SIV specific lysis was low or undetectable, even after four immunizations. However, stable SIV Gag Poland env-specific T-cell clones (CD3+ CD8+) were isolated after only two DNA immunizations, and Gag Pol- and Nef-specific CTL lines were isolated on the day of challenge. All animals were challenged at week 38 with SIVmne uncloned stock by the intrarectal route. Based on antibody anamnestic responses (western, ELISA, and neutralizing antibodies) and virus detection methods (co-culture of PBMC and LNMC, nested set PCR- of DNA from PBMC and LNMC, and plasma QC-PCR), there were major differences between the groups in the challenge outcome. Surprisingly, sustained low virus loads were observed only in the DNA group, suggesting that four immunizations with DNA only elicited more effective immune responses than two DNA primes combined with two protein boosts. Multigenic DNA vaccines such as these, bearing all structural and regulatory genes, show significant promise and may be a safe alternative to live-attenuated vaccines.",
keywords = "Antibody, CTL, Cytokine, Genetic immunization, HIV-1, SIV, Vaccines",
author = "Nancy Haigwood and Pierce, {Christopher C.} and Robertson, {Michael N.} and Watson, {Andrew J.} and Montefiori, {David C.} and Michael Rabin and Lynch, {John B.} and LaRene Kuller and Jannelle Thompson and Morton, {William R.} and Benveniste, {Raoul E.} and Hu, {Shiu Lok} and Philip Greenberg and Mossman, {Sally P.}",
year = "1999",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/S0165-2478(98)00156-4",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "66",
pages = "183--188",
journal = "Immunology Letters",
issn = "0165-2478",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1-3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Protection from pathogenic SIV challenge using multigenic DNA vaccines

AU - Haigwood, Nancy

AU - Pierce, Christopher C.

AU - Robertson, Michael N.

AU - Watson, Andrew J.

AU - Montefiori, David C.

AU - Rabin, Michael

AU - Lynch, John B.

AU - Kuller, LaRene

AU - Thompson, Jannelle

AU - Morton, William R.

AU - Benveniste, Raoul E.

AU - Hu, Shiu Lok

AU - Greenberg, Philip

AU - Mossman, Sally P.

PY - 1999/3/1

Y1 - 1999/3/1

N2 - To assess DNA immunization as a strategy for protecting against HIV infection in humans, we utilized SIVmne infection of Macaca fascicularis as a vaccine challenge model with moderate pathogenic potential. We compared the efficacy of DNA immunization alone and in combination with subunit protein boosts. All of the structural and regulatory genes of SIVmne clone 8 were cloned into mammalian expression vectors under the control of the CMV IE-1 promoter. Eight M. fascicularis were immunized twice with 3 mg of plasmid DNA divided between two sites; intramuscular and intradermal. Four primed macaques received a further two DNA immunizations at weeks 16-36, while the second group of four were boosted with 250 μg recombinant gp160 plus 250 μg recombinant Gag-Pol particles formulated in MF-59 adjuvant. Half of the controls received four immunizations of vector DNA; half received two vector DNA and two adjuvant immunizations. As expected, humoral immune responses were stronger in the macaques receiving subunit boosts, but responses were sustained in both groups. Significant neutralizing antibody titers to SIVmne were detected in one of the subunit-boosted animals and in none of the DNA- only animals prior to challenge. T-cell proliferative responses to gp160 and to Gag were detected in all immunized animals after three immunizations, anti these responses increased after four immunizations. Cytokine profiles in PHA- stimulated PBMC taken on the day of challenge showed trends toward Th1 responses in 2,4 macaques in the DNA vaccinated group and in 1/4 of the DNA plus subunit vaccinated macaques: Th2 responses in 3/4 DNA plus subunit- immunized macaques; and Th0 responses in 4/4 controls. In bulk CTL culture, SIV specific lysis was low or undetectable, even after four immunizations. However, stable SIV Gag Poland env-specific T-cell clones (CD3+ CD8+) were isolated after only two DNA immunizations, and Gag Pol- and Nef-specific CTL lines were isolated on the day of challenge. All animals were challenged at week 38 with SIVmne uncloned stock by the intrarectal route. Based on antibody anamnestic responses (western, ELISA, and neutralizing antibodies) and virus detection methods (co-culture of PBMC and LNMC, nested set PCR- of DNA from PBMC and LNMC, and plasma QC-PCR), there were major differences between the groups in the challenge outcome. Surprisingly, sustained low virus loads were observed only in the DNA group, suggesting that four immunizations with DNA only elicited more effective immune responses than two DNA primes combined with two protein boosts. Multigenic DNA vaccines such as these, bearing all structural and regulatory genes, show significant promise and may be a safe alternative to live-attenuated vaccines.

AB - To assess DNA immunization as a strategy for protecting against HIV infection in humans, we utilized SIVmne infection of Macaca fascicularis as a vaccine challenge model with moderate pathogenic potential. We compared the efficacy of DNA immunization alone and in combination with subunit protein boosts. All of the structural and regulatory genes of SIVmne clone 8 were cloned into mammalian expression vectors under the control of the CMV IE-1 promoter. Eight M. fascicularis were immunized twice with 3 mg of plasmid DNA divided between two sites; intramuscular and intradermal. Four primed macaques received a further two DNA immunizations at weeks 16-36, while the second group of four were boosted with 250 μg recombinant gp160 plus 250 μg recombinant Gag-Pol particles formulated in MF-59 adjuvant. Half of the controls received four immunizations of vector DNA; half received two vector DNA and two adjuvant immunizations. As expected, humoral immune responses were stronger in the macaques receiving subunit boosts, but responses were sustained in both groups. Significant neutralizing antibody titers to SIVmne were detected in one of the subunit-boosted animals and in none of the DNA- only animals prior to challenge. T-cell proliferative responses to gp160 and to Gag were detected in all immunized animals after three immunizations, anti these responses increased after four immunizations. Cytokine profiles in PHA- stimulated PBMC taken on the day of challenge showed trends toward Th1 responses in 2,4 macaques in the DNA vaccinated group and in 1/4 of the DNA plus subunit vaccinated macaques: Th2 responses in 3/4 DNA plus subunit- immunized macaques; and Th0 responses in 4/4 controls. In bulk CTL culture, SIV specific lysis was low or undetectable, even after four immunizations. However, stable SIV Gag Poland env-specific T-cell clones (CD3+ CD8+) were isolated after only two DNA immunizations, and Gag Pol- and Nef-specific CTL lines were isolated on the day of challenge. All animals were challenged at week 38 with SIVmne uncloned stock by the intrarectal route. Based on antibody anamnestic responses (western, ELISA, and neutralizing antibodies) and virus detection methods (co-culture of PBMC and LNMC, nested set PCR- of DNA from PBMC and LNMC, and plasma QC-PCR), there were major differences between the groups in the challenge outcome. Surprisingly, sustained low virus loads were observed only in the DNA group, suggesting that four immunizations with DNA only elicited more effective immune responses than two DNA primes combined with two protein boosts. Multigenic DNA vaccines such as these, bearing all structural and regulatory genes, show significant promise and may be a safe alternative to live-attenuated vaccines.

KW - Antibody

KW - CTL

KW - Cytokine

KW - Genetic immunization

KW - HIV-1

KW - SIV

KW - Vaccines

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0033011905&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0033011905&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/S0165-2478(98)00156-4

DO - 10.1016/S0165-2478(98)00156-4

M3 - Article

VL - 66

SP - 183

EP - 188

JO - Immunology Letters

JF - Immunology Letters

SN - 0165-2478

IS - 1-3

ER -