Positivity ratio and reaction index: Patch-test quality-control metrics applied to the North American Contact Dermatitis Group database

Erin M. Warshaw, David D. Nelsen, Denis Sasseville, Donald V. Belsito, Howard I. Maibach, Kathryn A. Zug, Joseph F. Fowler, James S. Taylor, Vincent A. DeLeo, James G. Marks, Frances Storrs, C. G Toby Mathias, Melanie D. Pratt, Robert L. Rietschel

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

31 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: The positivity ratio (PR) and reaction index (RI) characterize the ability of patch-test preparations to produce strong (++ or +++) reactions as opposed to weak (+), questionable, or irritant reactions. Objective: This study evaluates these measures for North American Contact Dermatitis Group (NACDG) patch-test preparations. Methods: The PR and RI were calculated for 79 NACDG standard allergens tested from 1994 to 2006 (n = 26,479 patients). The median values were used as cutoff values for "acceptable" versus "problematic" preparations. Results: The top 10 "acceptable" patch-test preparations (PR ≤ 55 and RI > 0.46) were mixed dialkyl thioureas 1% in petrolatum (pet), tixocortol-21-pivalate 1% pet, ethylenediamine dihydrochloride 1% pet, sesquiterpene lactone mix 0.1% pet, nickel sulfate 2.5% pet, bacitracin 20% pet, thimerosal 0.1% pet, epoxy resin 1% pet, colophony 20% pet, and mercaptobenzothiazole 1% pet. The most "problematic" patch-test preparations (PR > 55 and RI ≤ 0.46) were cocamidopropyl betaine 1% aqueous (aq), benzalkonium chloride 0.1% aq, jasmine absolute 2% pet, iodopropynyl butyl carbamate 0.1% pet, 2-bromo-2-nitropropane-1,3-diol 0.5% pet, methyldibromoglutaronitrile 0.4% pet, methyldibromoglutaronitrile/ phenoxyethanol 2% pet and 2.5% pet, dimethylol dihydroxyethyleneurea 4.5% aq, and clobetasol-17-propionate 1% pet. Conclusion: Caution should be used when interpreting reactions to "problematic" patch-test preparations with a high proportion of weak, irritant, and questionable reactions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)91-97
Number of pages7
JournalDermatitis
Volume21
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 2010
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Petrolatum
Patch Tests
Contact Dermatitis
Quality Control
Databases
ethylenediamine
Irritants
Jasminum
Clobetasol
Thimerosal
Benzalkonium Compounds
Epoxy Resins
Bacitracin
Thiourea
Carbamates

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Dermatology
  • Immunology and Allergy

Cite this

Warshaw, E. M., Nelsen, D. D., Sasseville, D., Belsito, D. V., Maibach, H. I., Zug, K. A., ... Rietschel, R. L. (2010). Positivity ratio and reaction index: Patch-test quality-control metrics applied to the North American Contact Dermatitis Group database. Dermatitis, 21(2), 91-97. https://doi.org/10.2310/6620.2010.09092

Positivity ratio and reaction index : Patch-test quality-control metrics applied to the North American Contact Dermatitis Group database. / Warshaw, Erin M.; Nelsen, David D.; Sasseville, Denis; Belsito, Donald V.; Maibach, Howard I.; Zug, Kathryn A.; Fowler, Joseph F.; Taylor, James S.; DeLeo, Vincent A.; Marks, James G.; Storrs, Frances; Mathias, C. G Toby; Pratt, Melanie D.; Rietschel, Robert L.

In: Dermatitis, Vol. 21, No. 2, 04.2010, p. 91-97.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Warshaw, EM, Nelsen, DD, Sasseville, D, Belsito, DV, Maibach, HI, Zug, KA, Fowler, JF, Taylor, JS, DeLeo, VA, Marks, JG, Storrs, F, Mathias, CGT, Pratt, MD & Rietschel, RL 2010, 'Positivity ratio and reaction index: Patch-test quality-control metrics applied to the North American Contact Dermatitis Group database', Dermatitis, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 91-97. https://doi.org/10.2310/6620.2010.09092
Warshaw, Erin M. ; Nelsen, David D. ; Sasseville, Denis ; Belsito, Donald V. ; Maibach, Howard I. ; Zug, Kathryn A. ; Fowler, Joseph F. ; Taylor, James S. ; DeLeo, Vincent A. ; Marks, James G. ; Storrs, Frances ; Mathias, C. G Toby ; Pratt, Melanie D. ; Rietschel, Robert L. / Positivity ratio and reaction index : Patch-test quality-control metrics applied to the North American Contact Dermatitis Group database. In: Dermatitis. 2010 ; Vol. 21, No. 2. pp. 91-97.
@article{17704f1ba3ff40c8a238693de60bbea9,
title = "Positivity ratio and reaction index: Patch-test quality-control metrics applied to the North American Contact Dermatitis Group database",
abstract = "Background: The positivity ratio (PR) and reaction index (RI) characterize the ability of patch-test preparations to produce strong (++ or +++) reactions as opposed to weak (+), questionable, or irritant reactions. Objective: This study evaluates these measures for North American Contact Dermatitis Group (NACDG) patch-test preparations. Methods: The PR and RI were calculated for 79 NACDG standard allergens tested from 1994 to 2006 (n = 26,479 patients). The median values were used as cutoff values for {"}acceptable{"} versus {"}problematic{"} preparations. Results: The top 10 {"}acceptable{"} patch-test preparations (PR ≤ 55 and RI > 0.46) were mixed dialkyl thioureas 1{\%} in petrolatum (pet), tixocortol-21-pivalate 1{\%} pet, ethylenediamine dihydrochloride 1{\%} pet, sesquiterpene lactone mix 0.1{\%} pet, nickel sulfate 2.5{\%} pet, bacitracin 20{\%} pet, thimerosal 0.1{\%} pet, epoxy resin 1{\%} pet, colophony 20{\%} pet, and mercaptobenzothiazole 1{\%} pet. The most {"}problematic{"} patch-test preparations (PR > 55 and RI ≤ 0.46) were cocamidopropyl betaine 1{\%} aqueous (aq), benzalkonium chloride 0.1{\%} aq, jasmine absolute 2{\%} pet, iodopropynyl butyl carbamate 0.1{\%} pet, 2-bromo-2-nitropropane-1,3-diol 0.5{\%} pet, methyldibromoglutaronitrile 0.4{\%} pet, methyldibromoglutaronitrile/ phenoxyethanol 2{\%} pet and 2.5{\%} pet, dimethylol dihydroxyethyleneurea 4.5{\%} aq, and clobetasol-17-propionate 1{\%} pet. Conclusion: Caution should be used when interpreting reactions to {"}problematic{"} patch-test preparations with a high proportion of weak, irritant, and questionable reactions.",
author = "Warshaw, {Erin M.} and Nelsen, {David D.} and Denis Sasseville and Belsito, {Donald V.} and Maibach, {Howard I.} and Zug, {Kathryn A.} and Fowler, {Joseph F.} and Taylor, {James S.} and DeLeo, {Vincent A.} and Marks, {James G.} and Frances Storrs and Mathias, {C. G Toby} and Pratt, {Melanie D.} and Rietschel, {Robert L.}",
year = "2010",
month = "4",
doi = "10.2310/6620.2010.09092",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "21",
pages = "91--97",
journal = "Dermatitis : contact, atopic, occupational, drug",
issn = "1710-3568",
publisher = "Decker Publishing",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Positivity ratio and reaction index

T2 - Patch-test quality-control metrics applied to the North American Contact Dermatitis Group database

AU - Warshaw, Erin M.

AU - Nelsen, David D.

AU - Sasseville, Denis

AU - Belsito, Donald V.

AU - Maibach, Howard I.

AU - Zug, Kathryn A.

AU - Fowler, Joseph F.

AU - Taylor, James S.

AU - DeLeo, Vincent A.

AU - Marks, James G.

AU - Storrs, Frances

AU - Mathias, C. G Toby

AU - Pratt, Melanie D.

AU - Rietschel, Robert L.

PY - 2010/4

Y1 - 2010/4

N2 - Background: The positivity ratio (PR) and reaction index (RI) characterize the ability of patch-test preparations to produce strong (++ or +++) reactions as opposed to weak (+), questionable, or irritant reactions. Objective: This study evaluates these measures for North American Contact Dermatitis Group (NACDG) patch-test preparations. Methods: The PR and RI were calculated for 79 NACDG standard allergens tested from 1994 to 2006 (n = 26,479 patients). The median values were used as cutoff values for "acceptable" versus "problematic" preparations. Results: The top 10 "acceptable" patch-test preparations (PR ≤ 55 and RI > 0.46) were mixed dialkyl thioureas 1% in petrolatum (pet), tixocortol-21-pivalate 1% pet, ethylenediamine dihydrochloride 1% pet, sesquiterpene lactone mix 0.1% pet, nickel sulfate 2.5% pet, bacitracin 20% pet, thimerosal 0.1% pet, epoxy resin 1% pet, colophony 20% pet, and mercaptobenzothiazole 1% pet. The most "problematic" patch-test preparations (PR > 55 and RI ≤ 0.46) were cocamidopropyl betaine 1% aqueous (aq), benzalkonium chloride 0.1% aq, jasmine absolute 2% pet, iodopropynyl butyl carbamate 0.1% pet, 2-bromo-2-nitropropane-1,3-diol 0.5% pet, methyldibromoglutaronitrile 0.4% pet, methyldibromoglutaronitrile/ phenoxyethanol 2% pet and 2.5% pet, dimethylol dihydroxyethyleneurea 4.5% aq, and clobetasol-17-propionate 1% pet. Conclusion: Caution should be used when interpreting reactions to "problematic" patch-test preparations with a high proportion of weak, irritant, and questionable reactions.

AB - Background: The positivity ratio (PR) and reaction index (RI) characterize the ability of patch-test preparations to produce strong (++ or +++) reactions as opposed to weak (+), questionable, or irritant reactions. Objective: This study evaluates these measures for North American Contact Dermatitis Group (NACDG) patch-test preparations. Methods: The PR and RI were calculated for 79 NACDG standard allergens tested from 1994 to 2006 (n = 26,479 patients). The median values were used as cutoff values for "acceptable" versus "problematic" preparations. Results: The top 10 "acceptable" patch-test preparations (PR ≤ 55 and RI > 0.46) were mixed dialkyl thioureas 1% in petrolatum (pet), tixocortol-21-pivalate 1% pet, ethylenediamine dihydrochloride 1% pet, sesquiterpene lactone mix 0.1% pet, nickel sulfate 2.5% pet, bacitracin 20% pet, thimerosal 0.1% pet, epoxy resin 1% pet, colophony 20% pet, and mercaptobenzothiazole 1% pet. The most "problematic" patch-test preparations (PR > 55 and RI ≤ 0.46) were cocamidopropyl betaine 1% aqueous (aq), benzalkonium chloride 0.1% aq, jasmine absolute 2% pet, iodopropynyl butyl carbamate 0.1% pet, 2-bromo-2-nitropropane-1,3-diol 0.5% pet, methyldibromoglutaronitrile 0.4% pet, methyldibromoglutaronitrile/ phenoxyethanol 2% pet and 2.5% pet, dimethylol dihydroxyethyleneurea 4.5% aq, and clobetasol-17-propionate 1% pet. Conclusion: Caution should be used when interpreting reactions to "problematic" patch-test preparations with a high proportion of weak, irritant, and questionable reactions.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77949592500&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77949592500&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2310/6620.2010.09092

DO - 10.2310/6620.2010.09092

M3 - Article

C2 - 20233547

AN - SCOPUS:77949592500

VL - 21

SP - 91

EP - 97

JO - Dermatitis : contact, atopic, occupational, drug

JF - Dermatitis : contact, atopic, occupational, drug

SN - 1710-3568

IS - 2

ER -