A randomized trial of lansoprazole, amoxycillin, and clarithromycin versus lansoprazole, bismuth, metronidazole and tetracycline in the retreatment of patients failing initial helicobacter pylori therapy

Nathan Magaret, Michael Burm, Douglas Faigel, Carolyn Kelly, Walter Peterson, M (Brian) Fennerty

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

28 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background/Aim: 10-30% of the patients treated for Helicobacter pylori fail to clear the infection after initial therapy. Little is known as to the efficacy of retreatment regimens in these patients. Proton pump inhibitor (PPI)-based triple and quadruple therapies demonstrate efficacies of 80-90% as initial therapy for H. pylori infection, but whether these regimens are as effective when used for retreatment is unknown. The efficacy of a metronidazole-containing regimen in this situation is also unknown. Our aim was to compare the efficacy of a nonmetronidazole-containing PPI-based triple versus a PPI-based quadruple therapy containing metronidazole in patients failing previous H. pylori therapy. Methods: 48 patients were enrolled in this study at two sites after failure of previous H. pylori therapy as determined by a positive 14C-urea breath test. Patients were stratified by prior treatment with a metronidazole-containing regimen and were then randomized to either lansoprazole (L) 30 mg twice daily, amoxycillin (A) 1,000 mg twice daily, and clarithromycin (C) 500 mg twice daily for 14 days (LAC) or L 30 mg four times daily, bismuth subsalicylate (B) 2 tablets four times daily, metronidazole (M) 250 mg four times daily and tetracycline (T) 250 mg four times daily for 14 days (LBMT). Side effects and compliance (pill count) were assessed at the completion of therapy. A repeat 14C-urea breath test was performed 4 or more weeks after completion of therapy, and cure was defined as a negative test result. Results: 48 patients (16 males and 32 females) were enrolled in this study. 20 patients received LAC (18 prior M), and 28 received LBMT (23 prior M). Per protocol and intention-to-treat efficacies were 82% (95% CI 64-100%) and 75% (95% CI 56-94%) for LAC and 80% (96% CI 64-96%) and 71% (95% CI 54-88%) for LBMT (p = 0.85 per protocol and p = 0.78 intention to treat between LAC and LBMT), respectively. The compliance (≥80% of pills taken) was found to be 89% in both treatment groups. Side effects were noted in 84% for LAC and in 82% for LBMT, but were mild and did not cause discontinuation of therapy. Conclusions: PPI-based triple and quadruple therapy with both LAC and LBMT are effective in retreating patients failing initial metronidazole-based H. pylori therapies. LAC was not statistically superior to LBMT as a 'retreatment' regimen in this clinical situation, but the small sample size and wide confidence limits do not preclude the possibility of a smaller but significant difference in efficacy between the regimens. To determine whether LAC or LBMT is as effective for retreating patients failing non-metronidazole-containing regimens requires further study.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)174-178
Number of pages5
JournalDigestive Diseases
Volume19
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - 2001

Fingerprint

Lansoprazole
Bismuth
Retreatment
Clarithromycin
Amoxicillin
Metronidazole
Tetracycline
Helicobacter pylori
Proton Pump Inhibitors
Therapeutics
Breath Tests
Compliance
Urea
L 30
Helicobacter Infections
Sample Size
Tablets

Keywords

  • Bismuth
  • Clarithromycin
  • Helicobacter pylori infection
  • Retreatment

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Gastroenterology

Cite this

A randomized trial of lansoprazole, amoxycillin, and clarithromycin versus lansoprazole, bismuth, metronidazole and tetracycline in the retreatment of patients failing initial helicobacter pylori therapy. / Magaret, Nathan; Burm, Michael; Faigel, Douglas; Kelly, Carolyn; Peterson, Walter; Fennerty, M (Brian).

In: Digestive Diseases, Vol. 19, No. 2, 2001, p. 174-178.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{868ccb0f3cd94824ab0ec3cc192bedae,
title = "A randomized trial of lansoprazole, amoxycillin, and clarithromycin versus lansoprazole, bismuth, metronidazole and tetracycline in the retreatment of patients failing initial helicobacter pylori therapy",
abstract = "Background/Aim: 10-30{\%} of the patients treated for Helicobacter pylori fail to clear the infection after initial therapy. Little is known as to the efficacy of retreatment regimens in these patients. Proton pump inhibitor (PPI)-based triple and quadruple therapies demonstrate efficacies of 80-90{\%} as initial therapy for H. pylori infection, but whether these regimens are as effective when used for retreatment is unknown. The efficacy of a metronidazole-containing regimen in this situation is also unknown. Our aim was to compare the efficacy of a nonmetronidazole-containing PPI-based triple versus a PPI-based quadruple therapy containing metronidazole in patients failing previous H. pylori therapy. Methods: 48 patients were enrolled in this study at two sites after failure of previous H. pylori therapy as determined by a positive 14C-urea breath test. Patients were stratified by prior treatment with a metronidazole-containing regimen and were then randomized to either lansoprazole (L) 30 mg twice daily, amoxycillin (A) 1,000 mg twice daily, and clarithromycin (C) 500 mg twice daily for 14 days (LAC) or L 30 mg four times daily, bismuth subsalicylate (B) 2 tablets four times daily, metronidazole (M) 250 mg four times daily and tetracycline (T) 250 mg four times daily for 14 days (LBMT). Side effects and compliance (pill count) were assessed at the completion of therapy. A repeat 14C-urea breath test was performed 4 or more weeks after completion of therapy, and cure was defined as a negative test result. Results: 48 patients (16 males and 32 females) were enrolled in this study. 20 patients received LAC (18 prior M), and 28 received LBMT (23 prior M). Per protocol and intention-to-treat efficacies were 82{\%} (95{\%} CI 64-100{\%}) and 75{\%} (95{\%} CI 56-94{\%}) for LAC and 80{\%} (96{\%} CI 64-96{\%}) and 71{\%} (95{\%} CI 54-88{\%}) for LBMT (p = 0.85 per protocol and p = 0.78 intention to treat between LAC and LBMT), respectively. The compliance (≥80{\%} of pills taken) was found to be 89{\%} in both treatment groups. Side effects were noted in 84{\%} for LAC and in 82{\%} for LBMT, but were mild and did not cause discontinuation of therapy. Conclusions: PPI-based triple and quadruple therapy with both LAC and LBMT are effective in retreating patients failing initial metronidazole-based H. pylori therapies. LAC was not statistically superior to LBMT as a 'retreatment' regimen in this clinical situation, but the small sample size and wide confidence limits do not preclude the possibility of a smaller but significant difference in efficacy between the regimens. To determine whether LAC or LBMT is as effective for retreating patients failing non-metronidazole-containing regimens requires further study.",
keywords = "Bismuth, Clarithromycin, Helicobacter pylori infection, Retreatment",
author = "Nathan Magaret and Michael Burm and Douglas Faigel and Carolyn Kelly and Walter Peterson and Fennerty, {M (Brian)}",
year = "2001",
doi = "10.1159/000050674",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "19",
pages = "174--178",
journal = "Digestive Diseases",
issn = "0257-2753",
publisher = "S. Karger AG",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A randomized trial of lansoprazole, amoxycillin, and clarithromycin versus lansoprazole, bismuth, metronidazole and tetracycline in the retreatment of patients failing initial helicobacter pylori therapy

AU - Magaret, Nathan

AU - Burm, Michael

AU - Faigel, Douglas

AU - Kelly, Carolyn

AU - Peterson, Walter

AU - Fennerty, M (Brian)

PY - 2001

Y1 - 2001

N2 - Background/Aim: 10-30% of the patients treated for Helicobacter pylori fail to clear the infection after initial therapy. Little is known as to the efficacy of retreatment regimens in these patients. Proton pump inhibitor (PPI)-based triple and quadruple therapies demonstrate efficacies of 80-90% as initial therapy for H. pylori infection, but whether these regimens are as effective when used for retreatment is unknown. The efficacy of a metronidazole-containing regimen in this situation is also unknown. Our aim was to compare the efficacy of a nonmetronidazole-containing PPI-based triple versus a PPI-based quadruple therapy containing metronidazole in patients failing previous H. pylori therapy. Methods: 48 patients were enrolled in this study at two sites after failure of previous H. pylori therapy as determined by a positive 14C-urea breath test. Patients were stratified by prior treatment with a metronidazole-containing regimen and were then randomized to either lansoprazole (L) 30 mg twice daily, amoxycillin (A) 1,000 mg twice daily, and clarithromycin (C) 500 mg twice daily for 14 days (LAC) or L 30 mg four times daily, bismuth subsalicylate (B) 2 tablets four times daily, metronidazole (M) 250 mg four times daily and tetracycline (T) 250 mg four times daily for 14 days (LBMT). Side effects and compliance (pill count) were assessed at the completion of therapy. A repeat 14C-urea breath test was performed 4 or more weeks after completion of therapy, and cure was defined as a negative test result. Results: 48 patients (16 males and 32 females) were enrolled in this study. 20 patients received LAC (18 prior M), and 28 received LBMT (23 prior M). Per protocol and intention-to-treat efficacies were 82% (95% CI 64-100%) and 75% (95% CI 56-94%) for LAC and 80% (96% CI 64-96%) and 71% (95% CI 54-88%) for LBMT (p = 0.85 per protocol and p = 0.78 intention to treat between LAC and LBMT), respectively. The compliance (≥80% of pills taken) was found to be 89% in both treatment groups. Side effects were noted in 84% for LAC and in 82% for LBMT, but were mild and did not cause discontinuation of therapy. Conclusions: PPI-based triple and quadruple therapy with both LAC and LBMT are effective in retreating patients failing initial metronidazole-based H. pylori therapies. LAC was not statistically superior to LBMT as a 'retreatment' regimen in this clinical situation, but the small sample size and wide confidence limits do not preclude the possibility of a smaller but significant difference in efficacy between the regimens. To determine whether LAC or LBMT is as effective for retreating patients failing non-metronidazole-containing regimens requires further study.

AB - Background/Aim: 10-30% of the patients treated for Helicobacter pylori fail to clear the infection after initial therapy. Little is known as to the efficacy of retreatment regimens in these patients. Proton pump inhibitor (PPI)-based triple and quadruple therapies demonstrate efficacies of 80-90% as initial therapy for H. pylori infection, but whether these regimens are as effective when used for retreatment is unknown. The efficacy of a metronidazole-containing regimen in this situation is also unknown. Our aim was to compare the efficacy of a nonmetronidazole-containing PPI-based triple versus a PPI-based quadruple therapy containing metronidazole in patients failing previous H. pylori therapy. Methods: 48 patients were enrolled in this study at two sites after failure of previous H. pylori therapy as determined by a positive 14C-urea breath test. Patients were stratified by prior treatment with a metronidazole-containing regimen and were then randomized to either lansoprazole (L) 30 mg twice daily, amoxycillin (A) 1,000 mg twice daily, and clarithromycin (C) 500 mg twice daily for 14 days (LAC) or L 30 mg four times daily, bismuth subsalicylate (B) 2 tablets four times daily, metronidazole (M) 250 mg four times daily and tetracycline (T) 250 mg four times daily for 14 days (LBMT). Side effects and compliance (pill count) were assessed at the completion of therapy. A repeat 14C-urea breath test was performed 4 or more weeks after completion of therapy, and cure was defined as a negative test result. Results: 48 patients (16 males and 32 females) were enrolled in this study. 20 patients received LAC (18 prior M), and 28 received LBMT (23 prior M). Per protocol and intention-to-treat efficacies were 82% (95% CI 64-100%) and 75% (95% CI 56-94%) for LAC and 80% (96% CI 64-96%) and 71% (95% CI 54-88%) for LBMT (p = 0.85 per protocol and p = 0.78 intention to treat between LAC and LBMT), respectively. The compliance (≥80% of pills taken) was found to be 89% in both treatment groups. Side effects were noted in 84% for LAC and in 82% for LBMT, but were mild and did not cause discontinuation of therapy. Conclusions: PPI-based triple and quadruple therapy with both LAC and LBMT are effective in retreating patients failing initial metronidazole-based H. pylori therapies. LAC was not statistically superior to LBMT as a 'retreatment' regimen in this clinical situation, but the small sample size and wide confidence limits do not preclude the possibility of a smaller but significant difference in efficacy between the regimens. To determine whether LAC or LBMT is as effective for retreating patients failing non-metronidazole-containing regimens requires further study.

KW - Bismuth

KW - Clarithromycin

KW - Helicobacter pylori infection

KW - Retreatment

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0034847354&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0034847354&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1159/000050674

DO - 10.1159/000050674

M3 - Article

C2 - 11549829

AN - SCOPUS:0034847354

VL - 19

SP - 174

EP - 178

JO - Digestive Diseases

JF - Digestive Diseases

SN - 0257-2753

IS - 2

ER -