Using a 2-variable method in radionuclide shuntography to predict shunt patency

Eric M. Thompson, Kate Wagner, Kassi Kronfeld, Nathan Selden

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

OBJECT: Radionuclide shuntography interpretation is uncertain when the tracer fails to enter the ventricles but quickly drains distally or when the tracer enters the ventricles but takes longer than 15 minutes to drain distally. The purpose of this study was to aid in the clinical interpretation of a variety of shuntography results and to determine the applicability of shuntography in different patient populations.

METHODS: The results of 259 shuntograms were reviewed. Chi-square analysis was performed to evaluate the relationship between clinical variables and shuntography results. Two-by-two binary classification analyses were performed to determine the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value for 4 different combinatorial types of shuntography results based on 2 variables: ventricular tracer entry and distal tracer drainage.

RESULTS: Median patient age was 19 years, and 51% of patients were male. The most common presentation in patients undergoing shuntography was headache (169/254, 66.5%) with radiographically stable ventricle size. Of 227 patients with available imaging data, 163 (71.8%) presented with the same ventricle size as shown on a previous asymptomatic scan, 43 (18.9%) had larger ventricles, and 21 (9.2%) had smaller ventricles. Within 30 days of shuntography, 74 of 259 patients (28.6%) underwent surgical shunt exploration: 65 were found to have an obstructed shunt and 9 were found to have a patent shunt. Of those patients not undergoing surgery, the median length of benign clinical follow-up was 1051 days. Clinical variables were not significantly associated with shuntography results, including valve type (p = 0.180), ventricle size (p = 0.556), age (p = 0.549), distal drainage site (p = 0.098), and hydrocephalus etiology (p = 0.937). Shuntography results of patients with myelomeningocele were not dissociable from those of the group as a whole. Sensitivity to diagnose shunt failure was lowest (37.5%) but specificity was highest (97.2%) when the definition of a "normal" shuntogram included any tracer movement into the distal site within 45 minutes. Conversely, sensitivity was highest (87.5%) and specificity was lowest (51.4%) when the definition was limited exclusively to tracer entry into the ventricles and distal drainage within 15 minutes.

CONCLUSIONS: Even with a stringent definition of a "normal" shuntogram, sensitivity and specificity were relatively low for a diagnostic test. Clinical variables such as valve type, ventricle size, patient age, distal drainage site, and etiology of hydrocephalus were not associated with shuntography results.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1504-1507
Number of pages4
JournalJournal of Neurosurgery
Volume121
Issue number6
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 1 2014

Fingerprint

Radioisotopes
Drainage
Hydrocephalus
Sensitivity and Specificity
Meningomyelocele
Routine Diagnostic Tests
Headache
Population

Keywords

  • hydrocephalus
  • NPV = negative predictive value
  • OHSU = Oregon Health & Science University
  • PPV = positive predictive value
  • radionuclide shuntogram
  • sensitivity
  • shunt obstruction
  • specificity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Using a 2-variable method in radionuclide shuntography to predict shunt patency. / Thompson, Eric M.; Wagner, Kate; Kronfeld, Kassi; Selden, Nathan.

In: Journal of Neurosurgery, Vol. 121, No. 6, 01.12.2014, p. 1504-1507.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Thompson, Eric M. ; Wagner, Kate ; Kronfeld, Kassi ; Selden, Nathan. / Using a 2-variable method in radionuclide shuntography to predict shunt patency. In: Journal of Neurosurgery. 2014 ; Vol. 121, No. 6. pp. 1504-1507.
@article{da5f73c0b95e4eb8a411ae1c54c29383,
title = "Using a 2-variable method in radionuclide shuntography to predict shunt patency",
abstract = "OBJECT: Radionuclide shuntography interpretation is uncertain when the tracer fails to enter the ventricles but quickly drains distally or when the tracer enters the ventricles but takes longer than 15 minutes to drain distally. The purpose of this study was to aid in the clinical interpretation of a variety of shuntography results and to determine the applicability of shuntography in different patient populations.METHODS: The results of 259 shuntograms were reviewed. Chi-square analysis was performed to evaluate the relationship between clinical variables and shuntography results. Two-by-two binary classification analyses were performed to determine the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value for 4 different combinatorial types of shuntography results based on 2 variables: ventricular tracer entry and distal tracer drainage.RESULTS: Median patient age was 19 years, and 51{\%} of patients were male. The most common presentation in patients undergoing shuntography was headache (169/254, 66.5{\%}) with radiographically stable ventricle size. Of 227 patients with available imaging data, 163 (71.8{\%}) presented with the same ventricle size as shown on a previous asymptomatic scan, 43 (18.9{\%}) had larger ventricles, and 21 (9.2{\%}) had smaller ventricles. Within 30 days of shuntography, 74 of 259 patients (28.6{\%}) underwent surgical shunt exploration: 65 were found to have an obstructed shunt and 9 were found to have a patent shunt. Of those patients not undergoing surgery, the median length of benign clinical follow-up was 1051 days. Clinical variables were not significantly associated with shuntography results, including valve type (p = 0.180), ventricle size (p = 0.556), age (p = 0.549), distal drainage site (p = 0.098), and hydrocephalus etiology (p = 0.937). Shuntography results of patients with myelomeningocele were not dissociable from those of the group as a whole. Sensitivity to diagnose shunt failure was lowest (37.5{\%}) but specificity was highest (97.2{\%}) when the definition of a {"}normal{"} shuntogram included any tracer movement into the distal site within 45 minutes. Conversely, sensitivity was highest (87.5{\%}) and specificity was lowest (51.4{\%}) when the definition was limited exclusively to tracer entry into the ventricles and distal drainage within 15 minutes.CONCLUSIONS: Even with a stringent definition of a {"}normal{"} shuntogram, sensitivity and specificity were relatively low for a diagnostic test. Clinical variables such as valve type, ventricle size, patient age, distal drainage site, and etiology of hydrocephalus were not associated with shuntography results.",
keywords = "hydrocephalus, NPV = negative predictive value, OHSU = Oregon Health & Science University, PPV = positive predictive value, radionuclide shuntogram, sensitivity, shunt obstruction, specificity",
author = "Thompson, {Eric M.} and Kate Wagner and Kassi Kronfeld and Nathan Selden",
year = "2014",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3171/2014.8.JNS132898",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "121",
pages = "1504--1507",
journal = "Journal of Neurosurgery",
issn = "0022-3085",
publisher = "American Association of Neurological Surgeons",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Using a 2-variable method in radionuclide shuntography to predict shunt patency

AU - Thompson, Eric M.

AU - Wagner, Kate

AU - Kronfeld, Kassi

AU - Selden, Nathan

PY - 2014/12/1

Y1 - 2014/12/1

N2 - OBJECT: Radionuclide shuntography interpretation is uncertain when the tracer fails to enter the ventricles but quickly drains distally or when the tracer enters the ventricles but takes longer than 15 minutes to drain distally. The purpose of this study was to aid in the clinical interpretation of a variety of shuntography results and to determine the applicability of shuntography in different patient populations.METHODS: The results of 259 shuntograms were reviewed. Chi-square analysis was performed to evaluate the relationship between clinical variables and shuntography results. Two-by-two binary classification analyses were performed to determine the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value for 4 different combinatorial types of shuntography results based on 2 variables: ventricular tracer entry and distal tracer drainage.RESULTS: Median patient age was 19 years, and 51% of patients were male. The most common presentation in patients undergoing shuntography was headache (169/254, 66.5%) with radiographically stable ventricle size. Of 227 patients with available imaging data, 163 (71.8%) presented with the same ventricle size as shown on a previous asymptomatic scan, 43 (18.9%) had larger ventricles, and 21 (9.2%) had smaller ventricles. Within 30 days of shuntography, 74 of 259 patients (28.6%) underwent surgical shunt exploration: 65 were found to have an obstructed shunt and 9 were found to have a patent shunt. Of those patients not undergoing surgery, the median length of benign clinical follow-up was 1051 days. Clinical variables were not significantly associated with shuntography results, including valve type (p = 0.180), ventricle size (p = 0.556), age (p = 0.549), distal drainage site (p = 0.098), and hydrocephalus etiology (p = 0.937). Shuntography results of patients with myelomeningocele were not dissociable from those of the group as a whole. Sensitivity to diagnose shunt failure was lowest (37.5%) but specificity was highest (97.2%) when the definition of a "normal" shuntogram included any tracer movement into the distal site within 45 minutes. Conversely, sensitivity was highest (87.5%) and specificity was lowest (51.4%) when the definition was limited exclusively to tracer entry into the ventricles and distal drainage within 15 minutes.CONCLUSIONS: Even with a stringent definition of a "normal" shuntogram, sensitivity and specificity were relatively low for a diagnostic test. Clinical variables such as valve type, ventricle size, patient age, distal drainage site, and etiology of hydrocephalus were not associated with shuntography results.

AB - OBJECT: Radionuclide shuntography interpretation is uncertain when the tracer fails to enter the ventricles but quickly drains distally or when the tracer enters the ventricles but takes longer than 15 minutes to drain distally. The purpose of this study was to aid in the clinical interpretation of a variety of shuntography results and to determine the applicability of shuntography in different patient populations.METHODS: The results of 259 shuntograms were reviewed. Chi-square analysis was performed to evaluate the relationship between clinical variables and shuntography results. Two-by-two binary classification analyses were performed to determine the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value for 4 different combinatorial types of shuntography results based on 2 variables: ventricular tracer entry and distal tracer drainage.RESULTS: Median patient age was 19 years, and 51% of patients were male. The most common presentation in patients undergoing shuntography was headache (169/254, 66.5%) with radiographically stable ventricle size. Of 227 patients with available imaging data, 163 (71.8%) presented with the same ventricle size as shown on a previous asymptomatic scan, 43 (18.9%) had larger ventricles, and 21 (9.2%) had smaller ventricles. Within 30 days of shuntography, 74 of 259 patients (28.6%) underwent surgical shunt exploration: 65 were found to have an obstructed shunt and 9 were found to have a patent shunt. Of those patients not undergoing surgery, the median length of benign clinical follow-up was 1051 days. Clinical variables were not significantly associated with shuntography results, including valve type (p = 0.180), ventricle size (p = 0.556), age (p = 0.549), distal drainage site (p = 0.098), and hydrocephalus etiology (p = 0.937). Shuntography results of patients with myelomeningocele were not dissociable from those of the group as a whole. Sensitivity to diagnose shunt failure was lowest (37.5%) but specificity was highest (97.2%) when the definition of a "normal" shuntogram included any tracer movement into the distal site within 45 minutes. Conversely, sensitivity was highest (87.5%) and specificity was lowest (51.4%) when the definition was limited exclusively to tracer entry into the ventricles and distal drainage within 15 minutes.CONCLUSIONS: Even with a stringent definition of a "normal" shuntogram, sensitivity and specificity were relatively low for a diagnostic test. Clinical variables such as valve type, ventricle size, patient age, distal drainage site, and etiology of hydrocephalus were not associated with shuntography results.

KW - hydrocephalus

KW - NPV = negative predictive value

KW - OHSU = Oregon Health & Science University

KW - PPV = positive predictive value

KW - radionuclide shuntogram

KW - sensitivity

KW - shunt obstruction

KW - specificity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84925223575&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84925223575&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3171/2014.8.JNS132898

DO - 10.3171/2014.8.JNS132898

M3 - Article

VL - 121

SP - 1504

EP - 1507

JO - Journal of Neurosurgery

JF - Journal of Neurosurgery

SN - 0022-3085

IS - 6

ER -