Misleading presentation of breast cancer in popular magazines.

W. Burke, A. H. Olsen, L. E. Pinsky, S. E. Reynolds, Nancy Press

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

40 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

CONTEXT: Women commonly misunderstand their risk for breast cancer, overestimating both their risk for developing the disease at a young age and their lifetime risk. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether age bias occurs in popular media coverage of breast cancer. SELECTION STRATEGY: The search term breast cancer was used to identify 389 articles in U.S. magazines with a circulation of at least 500,000 published between January 1, 1993, and June 30, 1997. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Presence of age-related themes and age of patients with breast cancer who were described in vignettes. RESULTS: Age-related themes included breast cancer as a cause of premature death, breast cancer in mothers of young children, and the impact of a breast cancer diagnosis on dating and marriage. Factual information about age as a risk factor for breast cancer was presented in only 14% of articles, and age was often included in vignettes describing a woman with breast cancer. Thirty-four percent of the articles included one or more breast cancer vignettes. These articles included 172 unique vignettes in which patient age was described. In 84% of the vignettes (144 of 172), women were diagnosed with breast cancer before 50 years of age; in 47% (80 of 172), women were diagnosed before 40 years of age. On the basis of the age-specific incidence of breast cancer in the United States, the expected percentages would be 16% and 3.6%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Stories about breast cancer in popular U.S. magazines misrepresent the age distribution of the disease, emphasizing atypical cases of early-onset breast cancer and their social consequences. This presentation of breast cancer may contribute to women's fears of breast cancer and to overestimates of personal risk.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)58-64
Number of pages7
JournalEffective clinical practice : ECP
Volume4
Issue number2
StatePublished - 2001
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Breast Neoplasms
Premature Mortality
Age Distribution
Marriage
Fear
Cause of Death
Mothers
Outcome Assessment (Health Care)
Incidence

Cite this

Burke, W., Olsen, A. H., Pinsky, L. E., Reynolds, S. E., & Press, N. (2001). Misleading presentation of breast cancer in popular magazines. Effective clinical practice : ECP, 4(2), 58-64.

Misleading presentation of breast cancer in popular magazines. / Burke, W.; Olsen, A. H.; Pinsky, L. E.; Reynolds, S. E.; Press, Nancy.

In: Effective clinical practice : ECP, Vol. 4, No. 2, 2001, p. 58-64.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Burke, W, Olsen, AH, Pinsky, LE, Reynolds, SE & Press, N 2001, 'Misleading presentation of breast cancer in popular magazines.', Effective clinical practice : ECP, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 58-64.
Burke, W. ; Olsen, A. H. ; Pinsky, L. E. ; Reynolds, S. E. ; Press, Nancy. / Misleading presentation of breast cancer in popular magazines. In: Effective clinical practice : ECP. 2001 ; Vol. 4, No. 2. pp. 58-64.
@article{5bc74d64100744b7a49587edbb599649,
title = "Misleading presentation of breast cancer in popular magazines.",
abstract = "CONTEXT: Women commonly misunderstand their risk for breast cancer, overestimating both their risk for developing the disease at a young age and their lifetime risk. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether age bias occurs in popular media coverage of breast cancer. SELECTION STRATEGY: The search term breast cancer was used to identify 389 articles in U.S. magazines with a circulation of at least 500,000 published between January 1, 1993, and June 30, 1997. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Presence of age-related themes and age of patients with breast cancer who were described in vignettes. RESULTS: Age-related themes included breast cancer as a cause of premature death, breast cancer in mothers of young children, and the impact of a breast cancer diagnosis on dating and marriage. Factual information about age as a risk factor for breast cancer was presented in only 14{\%} of articles, and age was often included in vignettes describing a woman with breast cancer. Thirty-four percent of the articles included one or more breast cancer vignettes. These articles included 172 unique vignettes in which patient age was described. In 84{\%} of the vignettes (144 of 172), women were diagnosed with breast cancer before 50 years of age; in 47{\%} (80 of 172), women were diagnosed before 40 years of age. On the basis of the age-specific incidence of breast cancer in the United States, the expected percentages would be 16{\%} and 3.6{\%}, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Stories about breast cancer in popular U.S. magazines misrepresent the age distribution of the disease, emphasizing atypical cases of early-onset breast cancer and their social consequences. This presentation of breast cancer may contribute to women's fears of breast cancer and to overestimates of personal risk.",
author = "W. Burke and Olsen, {A. H.} and Pinsky, {L. E.} and Reynolds, {S. E.} and Nancy Press",
year = "2001",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "4",
pages = "58--64",
journal = "Effective clinical practice : ECP",
issn = "1099-8128",
publisher = "Alliance of Community Health Plans",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Misleading presentation of breast cancer in popular magazines.

AU - Burke, W.

AU - Olsen, A. H.

AU - Pinsky, L. E.

AU - Reynolds, S. E.

AU - Press, Nancy

PY - 2001

Y1 - 2001

N2 - CONTEXT: Women commonly misunderstand their risk for breast cancer, overestimating both their risk for developing the disease at a young age and their lifetime risk. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether age bias occurs in popular media coverage of breast cancer. SELECTION STRATEGY: The search term breast cancer was used to identify 389 articles in U.S. magazines with a circulation of at least 500,000 published between January 1, 1993, and June 30, 1997. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Presence of age-related themes and age of patients with breast cancer who were described in vignettes. RESULTS: Age-related themes included breast cancer as a cause of premature death, breast cancer in mothers of young children, and the impact of a breast cancer diagnosis on dating and marriage. Factual information about age as a risk factor for breast cancer was presented in only 14% of articles, and age was often included in vignettes describing a woman with breast cancer. Thirty-four percent of the articles included one or more breast cancer vignettes. These articles included 172 unique vignettes in which patient age was described. In 84% of the vignettes (144 of 172), women were diagnosed with breast cancer before 50 years of age; in 47% (80 of 172), women were diagnosed before 40 years of age. On the basis of the age-specific incidence of breast cancer in the United States, the expected percentages would be 16% and 3.6%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Stories about breast cancer in popular U.S. magazines misrepresent the age distribution of the disease, emphasizing atypical cases of early-onset breast cancer and their social consequences. This presentation of breast cancer may contribute to women's fears of breast cancer and to overestimates of personal risk.

AB - CONTEXT: Women commonly misunderstand their risk for breast cancer, overestimating both their risk for developing the disease at a young age and their lifetime risk. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether age bias occurs in popular media coverage of breast cancer. SELECTION STRATEGY: The search term breast cancer was used to identify 389 articles in U.S. magazines with a circulation of at least 500,000 published between January 1, 1993, and June 30, 1997. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Presence of age-related themes and age of patients with breast cancer who were described in vignettes. RESULTS: Age-related themes included breast cancer as a cause of premature death, breast cancer in mothers of young children, and the impact of a breast cancer diagnosis on dating and marriage. Factual information about age as a risk factor for breast cancer was presented in only 14% of articles, and age was often included in vignettes describing a woman with breast cancer. Thirty-four percent of the articles included one or more breast cancer vignettes. These articles included 172 unique vignettes in which patient age was described. In 84% of the vignettes (144 of 172), women were diagnosed with breast cancer before 50 years of age; in 47% (80 of 172), women were diagnosed before 40 years of age. On the basis of the age-specific incidence of breast cancer in the United States, the expected percentages would be 16% and 3.6%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Stories about breast cancer in popular U.S. magazines misrepresent the age distribution of the disease, emphasizing atypical cases of early-onset breast cancer and their social consequences. This presentation of breast cancer may contribute to women's fears of breast cancer and to overestimates of personal risk.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0035290290&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0035290290&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 11329986

AN - SCOPUS:0035290290

VL - 4

SP - 58

EP - 64

JO - Effective clinical practice : ECP

JF - Effective clinical practice : ECP

SN - 1099-8128

IS - 2

ER -