Magnetic resonance enterography features of small bowel Crohn's disease activity

An inter-rater reliability study of small bowel active inflammation in clinical practice setting

Richard Tsai, Aaron Mintz, Michael Lin, Joyce Mhlanga, Adeeti Chiplunker, Amber Salter, Matthew Ciorba, Parakkal Deepak, Kathryn Fowler

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objective: The aim of this study is to determine the interrater agreement in a clinical practice environment for the most commonly used magnetic resonance enterography (MRE) features of Crohn's disease (CD). Methods: CD patients with MRE's before and after treatment were retrospectively identified using search queries over a 7-year period (May 2017-September 2017). MRE features of CD comprising components of multiple CD scoring indices were scored by radiologists in the same segment of bowel. Agreement for nominal categorical and continuous variables was assessed using a κ and interclass correlation coefficients, respectively. Results: 80 scans comprised the study population. Moderate interrater agreement was seen in both the pre- and post-treatment MRE's for presence of diffusion restriction (κ = 0.43, 0.48; pre- and post-treatment), stricturing disease (κ = 0.51, 0.52), overall degree of severity (κ = 0.49, 0.59). Substantial agreement was seen in pre- and post-treatment scans for length of involvement (interclass correlation coefficient = 0.67, 0.61). The presence of mucosal ulceration had no agreement (κ = -0.07, -0.042). Conclusion: Many MRE features of active CD comprising the major CD scoring indices are reproducible when interpreted by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists. However, the presence of mucosal ulcerations had no agreement and may need more investigation before including this feature as a driver in therapeutic decision making. Advances in knowledge: Demonstrates the unreliability of mucosal ulceration by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists, targeting a potential area for future education. Key Points The majority of MRE findings incorporated in to many CD scoring indices have fair to moderate inter-rater agreement even when read by non-MRE expert radiologists. Substantial agreement was seen in the length of involved bowel, but this feature is only incorporated in to one of the CD scoring indices. Presence of mucosal ulcerations had no interrater agreement in our study-a feature which is heavily weighted by several CD scoring indices. Research should be focused bridging those features which have poor interrater agreement.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number20180930
JournalBritish Journal of Radiology
Volume92
Issue number1099
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Crohn Disease
Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy
Inflammation
Therapeutics
Decision Making
Education
Radiologists
Research
Population

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

Magnetic resonance enterography features of small bowel Crohn's disease activity : An inter-rater reliability study of small bowel active inflammation in clinical practice setting. / Tsai, Richard; Mintz, Aaron; Lin, Michael; Mhlanga, Joyce; Chiplunker, Adeeti; Salter, Amber; Ciorba, Matthew; Deepak, Parakkal; Fowler, Kathryn.

In: British Journal of Radiology, Vol. 92, No. 1099, 20180930, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Tsai, Richard ; Mintz, Aaron ; Lin, Michael ; Mhlanga, Joyce ; Chiplunker, Adeeti ; Salter, Amber ; Ciorba, Matthew ; Deepak, Parakkal ; Fowler, Kathryn. / Magnetic resonance enterography features of small bowel Crohn's disease activity : An inter-rater reliability study of small bowel active inflammation in clinical practice setting. In: British Journal of Radiology. 2019 ; Vol. 92, No. 1099.
@article{ce26df9fde3b4bab9d059c4c2c5d815e,
title = "Magnetic resonance enterography features of small bowel Crohn's disease activity: An inter-rater reliability study of small bowel active inflammation in clinical practice setting",
abstract = "Objective: The aim of this study is to determine the interrater agreement in a clinical practice environment for the most commonly used magnetic resonance enterography (MRE) features of Crohn's disease (CD). Methods: CD patients with MRE's before and after treatment were retrospectively identified using search queries over a 7-year period (May 2017-September 2017). MRE features of CD comprising components of multiple CD scoring indices were scored by radiologists in the same segment of bowel. Agreement for nominal categorical and continuous variables was assessed using a κ and interclass correlation coefficients, respectively. Results: 80 scans comprised the study population. Moderate interrater agreement was seen in both the pre- and post-treatment MRE's for presence of diffusion restriction (κ = 0.43, 0.48; pre- and post-treatment), stricturing disease (κ = 0.51, 0.52), overall degree of severity (κ = 0.49, 0.59). Substantial agreement was seen in pre- and post-treatment scans for length of involvement (interclass correlation coefficient = 0.67, 0.61). The presence of mucosal ulceration had no agreement (κ = -0.07, -0.042). Conclusion: Many MRE features of active CD comprising the major CD scoring indices are reproducible when interpreted by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists. However, the presence of mucosal ulcerations had no agreement and may need more investigation before including this feature as a driver in therapeutic decision making. Advances in knowledge: Demonstrates the unreliability of mucosal ulceration by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists, targeting a potential area for future education. Key Points The majority of MRE findings incorporated in to many CD scoring indices have fair to moderate inter-rater agreement even when read by non-MRE expert radiologists. Substantial agreement was seen in the length of involved bowel, but this feature is only incorporated in to one of the CD scoring indices. Presence of mucosal ulcerations had no interrater agreement in our study-a feature which is heavily weighted by several CD scoring indices. Research should be focused bridging those features which have poor interrater agreement.",
author = "Richard Tsai and Aaron Mintz and Michael Lin and Joyce Mhlanga and Adeeti Chiplunker and Amber Salter and Matthew Ciorba and Parakkal Deepak and Kathryn Fowler",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1259/bjr.20180930",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "92",
journal = "British Journal of Radiology",
issn = "0007-1285",
publisher = "British Institute of Radiology",
number = "1099",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Magnetic resonance enterography features of small bowel Crohn's disease activity

T2 - An inter-rater reliability study of small bowel active inflammation in clinical practice setting

AU - Tsai, Richard

AU - Mintz, Aaron

AU - Lin, Michael

AU - Mhlanga, Joyce

AU - Chiplunker, Adeeti

AU - Salter, Amber

AU - Ciorba, Matthew

AU - Deepak, Parakkal

AU - Fowler, Kathryn

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Objective: The aim of this study is to determine the interrater agreement in a clinical practice environment for the most commonly used magnetic resonance enterography (MRE) features of Crohn's disease (CD). Methods: CD patients with MRE's before and after treatment were retrospectively identified using search queries over a 7-year period (May 2017-September 2017). MRE features of CD comprising components of multiple CD scoring indices were scored by radiologists in the same segment of bowel. Agreement for nominal categorical and continuous variables was assessed using a κ and interclass correlation coefficients, respectively. Results: 80 scans comprised the study population. Moderate interrater agreement was seen in both the pre- and post-treatment MRE's for presence of diffusion restriction (κ = 0.43, 0.48; pre- and post-treatment), stricturing disease (κ = 0.51, 0.52), overall degree of severity (κ = 0.49, 0.59). Substantial agreement was seen in pre- and post-treatment scans for length of involvement (interclass correlation coefficient = 0.67, 0.61). The presence of mucosal ulceration had no agreement (κ = -0.07, -0.042). Conclusion: Many MRE features of active CD comprising the major CD scoring indices are reproducible when interpreted by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists. However, the presence of mucosal ulcerations had no agreement and may need more investigation before including this feature as a driver in therapeutic decision making. Advances in knowledge: Demonstrates the unreliability of mucosal ulceration by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists, targeting a potential area for future education. Key Points The majority of MRE findings incorporated in to many CD scoring indices have fair to moderate inter-rater agreement even when read by non-MRE expert radiologists. Substantial agreement was seen in the length of involved bowel, but this feature is only incorporated in to one of the CD scoring indices. Presence of mucosal ulcerations had no interrater agreement in our study-a feature which is heavily weighted by several CD scoring indices. Research should be focused bridging those features which have poor interrater agreement.

AB - Objective: The aim of this study is to determine the interrater agreement in a clinical practice environment for the most commonly used magnetic resonance enterography (MRE) features of Crohn's disease (CD). Methods: CD patients with MRE's before and after treatment were retrospectively identified using search queries over a 7-year period (May 2017-September 2017). MRE features of CD comprising components of multiple CD scoring indices were scored by radiologists in the same segment of bowel. Agreement for nominal categorical and continuous variables was assessed using a κ and interclass correlation coefficients, respectively. Results: 80 scans comprised the study population. Moderate interrater agreement was seen in both the pre- and post-treatment MRE's for presence of diffusion restriction (κ = 0.43, 0.48; pre- and post-treatment), stricturing disease (κ = 0.51, 0.52), overall degree of severity (κ = 0.49, 0.59). Substantial agreement was seen in pre- and post-treatment scans for length of involvement (interclass correlation coefficient = 0.67, 0.61). The presence of mucosal ulceration had no agreement (κ = -0.07, -0.042). Conclusion: Many MRE features of active CD comprising the major CD scoring indices are reproducible when interpreted by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists. However, the presence of mucosal ulcerations had no agreement and may need more investigation before including this feature as a driver in therapeutic decision making. Advances in knowledge: Demonstrates the unreliability of mucosal ulceration by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists, targeting a potential area for future education. Key Points The majority of MRE findings incorporated in to many CD scoring indices have fair to moderate inter-rater agreement even when read by non-MRE expert radiologists. Substantial agreement was seen in the length of involved bowel, but this feature is only incorporated in to one of the CD scoring indices. Presence of mucosal ulcerations had no interrater agreement in our study-a feature which is heavily weighted by several CD scoring indices. Research should be focused bridging those features which have poor interrater agreement.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85068488021&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85068488021&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1259/bjr.20180930

DO - 10.1259/bjr.20180930

M3 - Article

VL - 92

JO - British Journal of Radiology

JF - British Journal of Radiology

SN - 0007-1285

IS - 1099

M1 - 20180930

ER -