Limited clinical utility of a genetic risk score for the prediction of fracture risk in elderly subjects

Joel Eriksson, Daniel S. Evans, Carrie Nielson, Jian Shen, Priya Srikanth, Marc Hochberg, Shannon McWeeney, Peggy M. Cawthon, Beth Wilmot, Joseph Zmuda, Greg Tranah, Daniel B. Mirel, Sashi Challa, Michael Mooney, Andrew Crenshaw, Magnus Karlsson, Dan Mellström, Liesbeth Vandenput, Eric Orwoll, Claes Ohlsson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

It is important to identify the patients at highest risk of fractures. A recent large-scale meta-Analysis identified 63 autosomal singlenucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) associated with bone mineral density (BMD), of which 16 were also associated with fracture risk. Based on these findings, two genetic risk scores (GRS63 and GRS16) were developed. Our aim was to determine the clinical usefulness of these GRSs for the prediction of BMD, BMD change, and fracture risk in elderly subjects. We studied two male (Osteoporotic Fractures in Men Study [MrOS] US, MrOS Sweden) and one female (Study of Osteoporotic Fractures [SOF]) large prospective cohorts of older subjects, looking at BMD, BMD change, and radiographically and/or medically confirmed incident fractures (8067 subjects, 2185 incident nonvertebral or vertebral fractures). GRS63 was associated with BMD (≅3% of the variation explained) but not with BMD change. Both GRS63 and GRS16 were associated with fractures. After BMD adjustment, the effect sizes for these associations were substantially reduced. Similar results were found using an unweighted GRS63 and an unweighted GRS16 compared with those found using the corresponding weighted risk scores. Only minor improvements in C-statistics (AUC) for fractures were found when the GRSs were added to a base model (age, weight, and height), and no significant improvements in C-statistics were found when they were added to a model further adjusted for BMD. Net reclassification improvements with the addition of the GRSs to a base model were modest and substantially attenuated in BMD-Adjusted models. GRS63 is associated with BMD, but not BMD change, suggesting that the genetic determinants of BMD differ from those of BMD change. When BMD is known, the clinical utility of the two GRSs for fracture prediction is limited in elderly subjects.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)184-194
Number of pages11
JournalJournal of Bone and Mineral Research
Volume30
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2015

Fingerprint

Bone Density
Osteoporotic Fractures
Sweden
Area Under Curve
Meta-Analysis

Keywords

  • Dxa
  • Fracture risk assessment
  • General population studies
  • Human association studies
  • Osteoporosis

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine
  • Endocrinology, Diabetes and Metabolism

Cite this

Limited clinical utility of a genetic risk score for the prediction of fracture risk in elderly subjects. / Eriksson, Joel; Evans, Daniel S.; Nielson, Carrie; Shen, Jian; Srikanth, Priya; Hochberg, Marc; McWeeney, Shannon; Cawthon, Peggy M.; Wilmot, Beth; Zmuda, Joseph; Tranah, Greg; Mirel, Daniel B.; Challa, Sashi; Mooney, Michael; Crenshaw, Andrew; Karlsson, Magnus; Mellström, Dan; Vandenput, Liesbeth; Orwoll, Eric; Ohlsson, Claes.

In: Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, Vol. 30, No. 1, 01.01.2015, p. 184-194.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Eriksson, J, Evans, DS, Nielson, C, Shen, J, Srikanth, P, Hochberg, M, McWeeney, S, Cawthon, PM, Wilmot, B, Zmuda, J, Tranah, G, Mirel, DB, Challa, S, Mooney, M, Crenshaw, A, Karlsson, M, Mellström, D, Vandenput, L, Orwoll, E & Ohlsson, C 2015, 'Limited clinical utility of a genetic risk score for the prediction of fracture risk in elderly subjects', Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, vol. 30, no. 1, pp. 184-194. https://doi.org/10.1002/jbmr.2314
Eriksson, Joel ; Evans, Daniel S. ; Nielson, Carrie ; Shen, Jian ; Srikanth, Priya ; Hochberg, Marc ; McWeeney, Shannon ; Cawthon, Peggy M. ; Wilmot, Beth ; Zmuda, Joseph ; Tranah, Greg ; Mirel, Daniel B. ; Challa, Sashi ; Mooney, Michael ; Crenshaw, Andrew ; Karlsson, Magnus ; Mellström, Dan ; Vandenput, Liesbeth ; Orwoll, Eric ; Ohlsson, Claes. / Limited clinical utility of a genetic risk score for the prediction of fracture risk in elderly subjects. In: Journal of Bone and Mineral Research. 2015 ; Vol. 30, No. 1. pp. 184-194.
@article{be7d74cf82fb4e5a9b5cbb2e255c2837,
title = "Limited clinical utility of a genetic risk score for the prediction of fracture risk in elderly subjects",
abstract = "It is important to identify the patients at highest risk of fractures. A recent large-scale meta-Analysis identified 63 autosomal singlenucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) associated with bone mineral density (BMD), of which 16 were also associated with fracture risk. Based on these findings, two genetic risk scores (GRS63 and GRS16) were developed. Our aim was to determine the clinical usefulness of these GRSs for the prediction of BMD, BMD change, and fracture risk in elderly subjects. We studied two male (Osteoporotic Fractures in Men Study [MrOS] US, MrOS Sweden) and one female (Study of Osteoporotic Fractures [SOF]) large prospective cohorts of older subjects, looking at BMD, BMD change, and radiographically and/or medically confirmed incident fractures (8067 subjects, 2185 incident nonvertebral or vertebral fractures). GRS63 was associated with BMD (≅3{\%} of the variation explained) but not with BMD change. Both GRS63 and GRS16 were associated with fractures. After BMD adjustment, the effect sizes for these associations were substantially reduced. Similar results were found using an unweighted GRS63 and an unweighted GRS16 compared with those found using the corresponding weighted risk scores. Only minor improvements in C-statistics (AUC) for fractures were found when the GRSs were added to a base model (age, weight, and height), and no significant improvements in C-statistics were found when they were added to a model further adjusted for BMD. Net reclassification improvements with the addition of the GRSs to a base model were modest and substantially attenuated in BMD-Adjusted models. GRS63 is associated with BMD, but not BMD change, suggesting that the genetic determinants of BMD differ from those of BMD change. When BMD is known, the clinical utility of the two GRSs for fracture prediction is limited in elderly subjects.",
keywords = "Dxa, Fracture risk assessment, General population studies, Human association studies, Osteoporosis",
author = "Joel Eriksson and Evans, {Daniel S.} and Carrie Nielson and Jian Shen and Priya Srikanth and Marc Hochberg and Shannon McWeeney and Cawthon, {Peggy M.} and Beth Wilmot and Joseph Zmuda and Greg Tranah and Mirel, {Daniel B.} and Sashi Challa and Michael Mooney and Andrew Crenshaw and Magnus Karlsson and Dan Mellstr{\"o}m and Liesbeth Vandenput and Eric Orwoll and Claes Ohlsson",
year = "2015",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/jbmr.2314",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "30",
pages = "184--194",
journal = "Journal of Bone and Mineral Research",
issn = "0884-0431",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Limited clinical utility of a genetic risk score for the prediction of fracture risk in elderly subjects

AU - Eriksson, Joel

AU - Evans, Daniel S.

AU - Nielson, Carrie

AU - Shen, Jian

AU - Srikanth, Priya

AU - Hochberg, Marc

AU - McWeeney, Shannon

AU - Cawthon, Peggy M.

AU - Wilmot, Beth

AU - Zmuda, Joseph

AU - Tranah, Greg

AU - Mirel, Daniel B.

AU - Challa, Sashi

AU - Mooney, Michael

AU - Crenshaw, Andrew

AU - Karlsson, Magnus

AU - Mellström, Dan

AU - Vandenput, Liesbeth

AU - Orwoll, Eric

AU - Ohlsson, Claes

PY - 2015/1/1

Y1 - 2015/1/1

N2 - It is important to identify the patients at highest risk of fractures. A recent large-scale meta-Analysis identified 63 autosomal singlenucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) associated with bone mineral density (BMD), of which 16 were also associated with fracture risk. Based on these findings, two genetic risk scores (GRS63 and GRS16) were developed. Our aim was to determine the clinical usefulness of these GRSs for the prediction of BMD, BMD change, and fracture risk in elderly subjects. We studied two male (Osteoporotic Fractures in Men Study [MrOS] US, MrOS Sweden) and one female (Study of Osteoporotic Fractures [SOF]) large prospective cohorts of older subjects, looking at BMD, BMD change, and radiographically and/or medically confirmed incident fractures (8067 subjects, 2185 incident nonvertebral or vertebral fractures). GRS63 was associated with BMD (≅3% of the variation explained) but not with BMD change. Both GRS63 and GRS16 were associated with fractures. After BMD adjustment, the effect sizes for these associations were substantially reduced. Similar results were found using an unweighted GRS63 and an unweighted GRS16 compared with those found using the corresponding weighted risk scores. Only minor improvements in C-statistics (AUC) for fractures were found when the GRSs were added to a base model (age, weight, and height), and no significant improvements in C-statistics were found when they were added to a model further adjusted for BMD. Net reclassification improvements with the addition of the GRSs to a base model were modest and substantially attenuated in BMD-Adjusted models. GRS63 is associated with BMD, but not BMD change, suggesting that the genetic determinants of BMD differ from those of BMD change. When BMD is known, the clinical utility of the two GRSs for fracture prediction is limited in elderly subjects.

AB - It is important to identify the patients at highest risk of fractures. A recent large-scale meta-Analysis identified 63 autosomal singlenucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) associated with bone mineral density (BMD), of which 16 were also associated with fracture risk. Based on these findings, two genetic risk scores (GRS63 and GRS16) were developed. Our aim was to determine the clinical usefulness of these GRSs for the prediction of BMD, BMD change, and fracture risk in elderly subjects. We studied two male (Osteoporotic Fractures in Men Study [MrOS] US, MrOS Sweden) and one female (Study of Osteoporotic Fractures [SOF]) large prospective cohorts of older subjects, looking at BMD, BMD change, and radiographically and/or medically confirmed incident fractures (8067 subjects, 2185 incident nonvertebral or vertebral fractures). GRS63 was associated with BMD (≅3% of the variation explained) but not with BMD change. Both GRS63 and GRS16 were associated with fractures. After BMD adjustment, the effect sizes for these associations were substantially reduced. Similar results were found using an unweighted GRS63 and an unweighted GRS16 compared with those found using the corresponding weighted risk scores. Only minor improvements in C-statistics (AUC) for fractures were found when the GRSs were added to a base model (age, weight, and height), and no significant improvements in C-statistics were found when they were added to a model further adjusted for BMD. Net reclassification improvements with the addition of the GRSs to a base model were modest and substantially attenuated in BMD-Adjusted models. GRS63 is associated with BMD, but not BMD change, suggesting that the genetic determinants of BMD differ from those of BMD change. When BMD is known, the clinical utility of the two GRSs for fracture prediction is limited in elderly subjects.

KW - Dxa

KW - Fracture risk assessment

KW - General population studies

KW - Human association studies

KW - Osteoporosis

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84919918723&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84919918723&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/jbmr.2314

DO - 10.1002/jbmr.2314

M3 - Article

VL - 30

SP - 184

EP - 194

JO - Journal of Bone and Mineral Research

JF - Journal of Bone and Mineral Research

SN - 0884-0431

IS - 1

ER -