Influence of head trauma on outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy

Lon A. Schuh, Thomas R. Henry, Gail Frames, Mila Blaivas, Donald (Don) Ross, Ivo Dairy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

25 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: There is controversy in the literature regarding the importance of risk factors in developing epilepsy and seizure outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. Some of the existing studies may be biased because of patient selection and limitations in determining predisposition. Objective: To investigate the role of risk factors for epilepsy in determining outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. Patients and Methods: We identified 102 patients in a consecutive surgery series for epilepsy from a tertiary center with a minimum of 1-year postoperative follow-up. Risk factors for epilepsy were determined prospectively on at least 3 occasions before anterior temporal lobectomy. Risk factors investigated were a history of febrile convulsions, family history of epilepsy, significant head trauma, history of meningitis, history of encephalitis, or significant perinatal insult. Foreign tissue lesions on magnetic resonance imaging was also included if an anterior temporal lobectomy was performed for presumed dual pathologic findings (hippocampus and lesion). Outcome was determined using Engel's classification. For statistical analysis we used successive logistic regression analysis, X2 test, Fisher exact test, and t test. Results: Of the 102 patients, 13 had no identified risk factor for epilepsy, 49 had 1 identified risk factor, and 40 had more than 1. Frequencies were 39 febrile convulsions (15 complex febrile convulsions), 29 head trauma, 22 with lesions seen on magnetic resonance imaging, 12 history of meningitis, 2 history of encephalitis, 19 family history of epilepsy, and 4 perinatal insult. Seventy-one (70%) were classified as Engel's class I, with 56 patients continuously free of seizures at follow-up. Those without risk factor were as likely to be rendered free of seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy as those with a risk factor (P = .27). No risk factor alone or in combination was correlated with complete freedom from seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy, but the presence of head trauma, alone or in combination, was correlated with continued seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy (P = .03; odds ratio, 2.6). Better outcomes were not seen in those with head trauma before the age of 5 years (P = .57). These findings did not change if all those with lesions on magnetic resonance imaging were excluded in the analysis. Those with a history of head trauma were as likely to have pathologic evidence of mesial temporal sclerosis as others (P = .82). Conclusions: Patients with a history of significant head trauma are less likely to become free of seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy. No other risk factor correlated with a statistically significant greater or lesser chance of freedom from seizures. This information may be used in preoperative counseling of patients.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1325-1328
Number of pages4
JournalArchives of Neurology
Volume55
Issue number10
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 1998
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Anterior Temporal Lobectomy
Craniocerebral Trauma
Epilepsy
Seizures
Febrile Seizures
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Encephalitis
Meningitis
Trauma
Risk Factors
Sclerosis
History
Patient Selection
Counseling
Hippocampus

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Neuroscience(all)

Cite this

Influence of head trauma on outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. / Schuh, Lon A.; Henry, Thomas R.; Frames, Gail; Blaivas, Mila; Ross, Donald (Don); Dairy, Ivo.

In: Archives of Neurology, Vol. 55, No. 10, 10.1998, p. 1325-1328.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Schuh, LA, Henry, TR, Frames, G, Blaivas, M, Ross, DD & Dairy, I 1998, 'Influence of head trauma on outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy', Archives of Neurology, vol. 55, no. 10, pp. 1325-1328. https://doi.org/10.1001/archneur.55.10.1325
Schuh, Lon A. ; Henry, Thomas R. ; Frames, Gail ; Blaivas, Mila ; Ross, Donald (Don) ; Dairy, Ivo. / Influence of head trauma on outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. In: Archives of Neurology. 1998 ; Vol. 55, No. 10. pp. 1325-1328.
@article{230c64a7770d44b7a3410fbda906bea1,
title = "Influence of head trauma on outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy",
abstract = "Background: There is controversy in the literature regarding the importance of risk factors in developing epilepsy and seizure outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. Some of the existing studies may be biased because of patient selection and limitations in determining predisposition. Objective: To investigate the role of risk factors for epilepsy in determining outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. Patients and Methods: We identified 102 patients in a consecutive surgery series for epilepsy from a tertiary center with a minimum of 1-year postoperative follow-up. Risk factors for epilepsy were determined prospectively on at least 3 occasions before anterior temporal lobectomy. Risk factors investigated were a history of febrile convulsions, family history of epilepsy, significant head trauma, history of meningitis, history of encephalitis, or significant perinatal insult. Foreign tissue lesions on magnetic resonance imaging was also included if an anterior temporal lobectomy was performed for presumed dual pathologic findings (hippocampus and lesion). Outcome was determined using Engel's classification. For statistical analysis we used successive logistic regression analysis, X2 test, Fisher exact test, and t test. Results: Of the 102 patients, 13 had no identified risk factor for epilepsy, 49 had 1 identified risk factor, and 40 had more than 1. Frequencies were 39 febrile convulsions (15 complex febrile convulsions), 29 head trauma, 22 with lesions seen on magnetic resonance imaging, 12 history of meningitis, 2 history of encephalitis, 19 family history of epilepsy, and 4 perinatal insult. Seventy-one (70{\%}) were classified as Engel's class I, with 56 patients continuously free of seizures at follow-up. Those without risk factor were as likely to be rendered free of seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy as those with a risk factor (P = .27). No risk factor alone or in combination was correlated with complete freedom from seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy, but the presence of head trauma, alone or in combination, was correlated with continued seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy (P = .03; odds ratio, 2.6). Better outcomes were not seen in those with head trauma before the age of 5 years (P = .57). These findings did not change if all those with lesions on magnetic resonance imaging were excluded in the analysis. Those with a history of head trauma were as likely to have pathologic evidence of mesial temporal sclerosis as others (P = .82). Conclusions: Patients with a history of significant head trauma are less likely to become free of seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy. No other risk factor correlated with a statistically significant greater or lesser chance of freedom from seizures. This information may be used in preoperative counseling of patients.",
author = "Schuh, {Lon A.} and Henry, {Thomas R.} and Gail Frames and Mila Blaivas and Ross, {Donald (Don)} and Ivo Dairy",
year = "1998",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1001/archneur.55.10.1325",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "55",
pages = "1325--1328",
journal = "Archives of Neurology",
issn = "0003-9942",
publisher = "American Medical Association",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Influence of head trauma on outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy

AU - Schuh, Lon A.

AU - Henry, Thomas R.

AU - Frames, Gail

AU - Blaivas, Mila

AU - Ross, Donald (Don)

AU - Dairy, Ivo

PY - 1998/10

Y1 - 1998/10

N2 - Background: There is controversy in the literature regarding the importance of risk factors in developing epilepsy and seizure outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. Some of the existing studies may be biased because of patient selection and limitations in determining predisposition. Objective: To investigate the role of risk factors for epilepsy in determining outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. Patients and Methods: We identified 102 patients in a consecutive surgery series for epilepsy from a tertiary center with a minimum of 1-year postoperative follow-up. Risk factors for epilepsy were determined prospectively on at least 3 occasions before anterior temporal lobectomy. Risk factors investigated were a history of febrile convulsions, family history of epilepsy, significant head trauma, history of meningitis, history of encephalitis, or significant perinatal insult. Foreign tissue lesions on magnetic resonance imaging was also included if an anterior temporal lobectomy was performed for presumed dual pathologic findings (hippocampus and lesion). Outcome was determined using Engel's classification. For statistical analysis we used successive logistic regression analysis, X2 test, Fisher exact test, and t test. Results: Of the 102 patients, 13 had no identified risk factor for epilepsy, 49 had 1 identified risk factor, and 40 had more than 1. Frequencies were 39 febrile convulsions (15 complex febrile convulsions), 29 head trauma, 22 with lesions seen on magnetic resonance imaging, 12 history of meningitis, 2 history of encephalitis, 19 family history of epilepsy, and 4 perinatal insult. Seventy-one (70%) were classified as Engel's class I, with 56 patients continuously free of seizures at follow-up. Those without risk factor were as likely to be rendered free of seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy as those with a risk factor (P = .27). No risk factor alone or in combination was correlated with complete freedom from seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy, but the presence of head trauma, alone or in combination, was correlated with continued seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy (P = .03; odds ratio, 2.6). Better outcomes were not seen in those with head trauma before the age of 5 years (P = .57). These findings did not change if all those with lesions on magnetic resonance imaging were excluded in the analysis. Those with a history of head trauma were as likely to have pathologic evidence of mesial temporal sclerosis as others (P = .82). Conclusions: Patients with a history of significant head trauma are less likely to become free of seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy. No other risk factor correlated with a statistically significant greater or lesser chance of freedom from seizures. This information may be used in preoperative counseling of patients.

AB - Background: There is controversy in the literature regarding the importance of risk factors in developing epilepsy and seizure outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. Some of the existing studies may be biased because of patient selection and limitations in determining predisposition. Objective: To investigate the role of risk factors for epilepsy in determining outcome following anterior temporal lobectomy. Patients and Methods: We identified 102 patients in a consecutive surgery series for epilepsy from a tertiary center with a minimum of 1-year postoperative follow-up. Risk factors for epilepsy were determined prospectively on at least 3 occasions before anterior temporal lobectomy. Risk factors investigated were a history of febrile convulsions, family history of epilepsy, significant head trauma, history of meningitis, history of encephalitis, or significant perinatal insult. Foreign tissue lesions on magnetic resonance imaging was also included if an anterior temporal lobectomy was performed for presumed dual pathologic findings (hippocampus and lesion). Outcome was determined using Engel's classification. For statistical analysis we used successive logistic regression analysis, X2 test, Fisher exact test, and t test. Results: Of the 102 patients, 13 had no identified risk factor for epilepsy, 49 had 1 identified risk factor, and 40 had more than 1. Frequencies were 39 febrile convulsions (15 complex febrile convulsions), 29 head trauma, 22 with lesions seen on magnetic resonance imaging, 12 history of meningitis, 2 history of encephalitis, 19 family history of epilepsy, and 4 perinatal insult. Seventy-one (70%) were classified as Engel's class I, with 56 patients continuously free of seizures at follow-up. Those without risk factor were as likely to be rendered free of seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy as those with a risk factor (P = .27). No risk factor alone or in combination was correlated with complete freedom from seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy, but the presence of head trauma, alone or in combination, was correlated with continued seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy (P = .03; odds ratio, 2.6). Better outcomes were not seen in those with head trauma before the age of 5 years (P = .57). These findings did not change if all those with lesions on magnetic resonance imaging were excluded in the analysis. Those with a history of head trauma were as likely to have pathologic evidence of mesial temporal sclerosis as others (P = .82). Conclusions: Patients with a history of significant head trauma are less likely to become free of seizures following anterior temporal lobectomy. No other risk factor correlated with a statistically significant greater or lesser chance of freedom from seizures. This information may be used in preoperative counseling of patients.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0031692119&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0031692119&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1001/archneur.55.10.1325

DO - 10.1001/archneur.55.10.1325

M3 - Article

VL - 55

SP - 1325

EP - 1328

JO - Archives of Neurology

JF - Archives of Neurology

SN - 0003-9942

IS - 10

ER -