Impact of CPOE on mortality rates - Contradictory findings, important messages

Elske Ammenwerth, J. Talmon, Joan Ash, D. W. Bates, M. C. Beuscart-Zéphir, A. Duhamel, P. L. Elkin, R. M. Gardner, A. Geissbuhler

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

71 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective: To analyze the seemingly contradictory results of the Han study (Pediatrics 2005) and the Del Beccaro study (Pediatrics 2006), both analyzing the effect of CPOE systems on mortality rates in pediatric intensive care settings. Methods: Seven CPOE system experts from the United States and Europe comment on these papers. Results: The two studies are not contradictory, but almost non-comparable due to differences in design and implementation. They demonstrate the range of outcomes that can be obtained from introducing informatics applications in complex health care settings. Implementing informatics applications is a sociotechnical activity, which often depends more on the organizational context than on a specific technology. As health informaticians, we must not only learn from failures, but also avoid both uncritical scepticism that may arise from drawing overly general conclusions from one negative trial, as much as uncritical optimism from limited successful ones. Conclusion: The commentaries emphasize the need to promote systematic studies for assessing the socio-technical factors that influence the introduction of increasingly sophisticated informatics applications within complex organizations. The emergence of evidence-based health informatics will be based both on evaluation guidelines and implementation guidelines, both of which increase the chances of successful implementation. In addition, well-educated health informaticians are needed to manage and guide the implementation processes.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)586-593
Number of pages8
JournalMethods of Information in Medicine
Volume45
Issue number6
StatePublished - 2006

Fingerprint

Medical Order Entry Systems
Informatics
Mortality
Pediatrics
Health
Guidelines
Expert Systems
Critical Care
Organizations
Technology
Delivery of Health Care

Keywords

  • CPOE
  • Evaluation studies
  • Evidence-based health informatics
  • Mortality

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health Informatics
  • Health Information Management
  • Nursing(all)

Cite this

Ammenwerth, E., Talmon, J., Ash, J., Bates, D. W., Beuscart-Zéphir, M. C., Duhamel, A., ... Geissbuhler, A. (2006). Impact of CPOE on mortality rates - Contradictory findings, important messages. Methods of Information in Medicine, 45(6), 586-593.

Impact of CPOE on mortality rates - Contradictory findings, important messages. / Ammenwerth, Elske; Talmon, J.; Ash, Joan; Bates, D. W.; Beuscart-Zéphir, M. C.; Duhamel, A.; Elkin, P. L.; Gardner, R. M.; Geissbuhler, A.

In: Methods of Information in Medicine, Vol. 45, No. 6, 2006, p. 586-593.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ammenwerth, E, Talmon, J, Ash, J, Bates, DW, Beuscart-Zéphir, MC, Duhamel, A, Elkin, PL, Gardner, RM & Geissbuhler, A 2006, 'Impact of CPOE on mortality rates - Contradictory findings, important messages', Methods of Information in Medicine, vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 586-593.
Ammenwerth E, Talmon J, Ash J, Bates DW, Beuscart-Zéphir MC, Duhamel A et al. Impact of CPOE on mortality rates - Contradictory findings, important messages. Methods of Information in Medicine. 2006;45(6):586-593.
Ammenwerth, Elske ; Talmon, J. ; Ash, Joan ; Bates, D. W. ; Beuscart-Zéphir, M. C. ; Duhamel, A. ; Elkin, P. L. ; Gardner, R. M. ; Geissbuhler, A. / Impact of CPOE on mortality rates - Contradictory findings, important messages. In: Methods of Information in Medicine. 2006 ; Vol. 45, No. 6. pp. 586-593.
@article{43b8f2d942044391aec90bff525a0275,
title = "Impact of CPOE on mortality rates - Contradictory findings, important messages",
abstract = "Objective: To analyze the seemingly contradictory results of the Han study (Pediatrics 2005) and the Del Beccaro study (Pediatrics 2006), both analyzing the effect of CPOE systems on mortality rates in pediatric intensive care settings. Methods: Seven CPOE system experts from the United States and Europe comment on these papers. Results: The two studies are not contradictory, but almost non-comparable due to differences in design and implementation. They demonstrate the range of outcomes that can be obtained from introducing informatics applications in complex health care settings. Implementing informatics applications is a sociotechnical activity, which often depends more on the organizational context than on a specific technology. As health informaticians, we must not only learn from failures, but also avoid both uncritical scepticism that may arise from drawing overly general conclusions from one negative trial, as much as uncritical optimism from limited successful ones. Conclusion: The commentaries emphasize the need to promote systematic studies for assessing the socio-technical factors that influence the introduction of increasingly sophisticated informatics applications within complex organizations. The emergence of evidence-based health informatics will be based both on evaluation guidelines and implementation guidelines, both of which increase the chances of successful implementation. In addition, well-educated health informaticians are needed to manage and guide the implementation processes.",
keywords = "CPOE, Evaluation studies, Evidence-based health informatics, Mortality",
author = "Elske Ammenwerth and J. Talmon and Joan Ash and Bates, {D. W.} and Beuscart-Z{\'e}phir, {M. C.} and A. Duhamel and Elkin, {P. L.} and Gardner, {R. M.} and A. Geissbuhler",
year = "2006",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "45",
pages = "586--593",
journal = "Methods of Information in Medicine",
issn = "0026-1270",
publisher = "Schattauer GmbH",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Impact of CPOE on mortality rates - Contradictory findings, important messages

AU - Ammenwerth, Elske

AU - Talmon, J.

AU - Ash, Joan

AU - Bates, D. W.

AU - Beuscart-Zéphir, M. C.

AU - Duhamel, A.

AU - Elkin, P. L.

AU - Gardner, R. M.

AU - Geissbuhler, A.

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - Objective: To analyze the seemingly contradictory results of the Han study (Pediatrics 2005) and the Del Beccaro study (Pediatrics 2006), both analyzing the effect of CPOE systems on mortality rates in pediatric intensive care settings. Methods: Seven CPOE system experts from the United States and Europe comment on these papers. Results: The two studies are not contradictory, but almost non-comparable due to differences in design and implementation. They demonstrate the range of outcomes that can be obtained from introducing informatics applications in complex health care settings. Implementing informatics applications is a sociotechnical activity, which often depends more on the organizational context than on a specific technology. As health informaticians, we must not only learn from failures, but also avoid both uncritical scepticism that may arise from drawing overly general conclusions from one negative trial, as much as uncritical optimism from limited successful ones. Conclusion: The commentaries emphasize the need to promote systematic studies for assessing the socio-technical factors that influence the introduction of increasingly sophisticated informatics applications within complex organizations. The emergence of evidence-based health informatics will be based both on evaluation guidelines and implementation guidelines, both of which increase the chances of successful implementation. In addition, well-educated health informaticians are needed to manage and guide the implementation processes.

AB - Objective: To analyze the seemingly contradictory results of the Han study (Pediatrics 2005) and the Del Beccaro study (Pediatrics 2006), both analyzing the effect of CPOE systems on mortality rates in pediatric intensive care settings. Methods: Seven CPOE system experts from the United States and Europe comment on these papers. Results: The two studies are not contradictory, but almost non-comparable due to differences in design and implementation. They demonstrate the range of outcomes that can be obtained from introducing informatics applications in complex health care settings. Implementing informatics applications is a sociotechnical activity, which often depends more on the organizational context than on a specific technology. As health informaticians, we must not only learn from failures, but also avoid both uncritical scepticism that may arise from drawing overly general conclusions from one negative trial, as much as uncritical optimism from limited successful ones. Conclusion: The commentaries emphasize the need to promote systematic studies for assessing the socio-technical factors that influence the introduction of increasingly sophisticated informatics applications within complex organizations. The emergence of evidence-based health informatics will be based both on evaluation guidelines and implementation guidelines, both of which increase the chances of successful implementation. In addition, well-educated health informaticians are needed to manage and guide the implementation processes.

KW - CPOE

KW - Evaluation studies

KW - Evidence-based health informatics

KW - Mortality

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33845939423&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33845939423&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 17149499

AN - SCOPUS:33845939423

VL - 45

SP - 586

EP - 593

JO - Methods of Information in Medicine

JF - Methods of Information in Medicine

SN - 0026-1270

IS - 6

ER -