Current Status of Musculoskeletal Trauma Care Systems Worldwide

International Orthopaedic Trauma Study Consortium

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

BACKGROUND AND RATIONALE: Although general trauma care systems and their effects on mortality reduction have been studied, little is known of the current state of musculoskeletal trauma delivery globally, particularly in low-income (LI) and low middle-income (LMI) countries. The goal of this study is to assess and describe the development and availability of musculoskeletal trauma care delivery worldwide.

MATERIALS & METHODS: A questionnaire was developed to evaluate different characteristics of general and musculoskeletal trauma care systems, including general aspects of systems, education, access to care and pre- and posthospital care. Surgical leaders involved with musculoskeletal trauma care were contacted to participate in the survey.

RESULTS: Of the 170 surveys sent, 95 were returned for use for the study. Nearly 30 percent of surgeons reported a formalized and coordinated trauma system in their countries. Estimates for the number of surgeons providing musculoskeletal trauma per one million inhabitants varied from 2.6 in LI countries to 58.8 in high-income countries. Worldwide, 15% of those caring for musculoskeletal trauma are fellowship trained. The survey results indicate a lack of implemented musculoskeletal trauma care guidelines across countries, with even high-income countries reporting less than 50% availability in most categories. Seventy-nine percent of the populations from LI countries were estimated to have no form of health care insurance. Formalized emergency medical services were reportedly available in only 33% and 50% of LI and LMI countries, respectively. Surgeons from LI and LMI countries responded that improvements in the availability of equipment (100%), number and locations of trauma-designated hospitals (90%), and physician training programs (88%) were necessary in their countries. The survey also revealed a general lack of resources for postoperative and rehabilitation care, irrespective of the country's income level.

CONCLUSION: This study addresses the current state of musculoskeletal trauma care delivery worldwide. These results indicate a greater need for trauma system development and support, from prehospital through posthospital care. Optimization of these systems can lead to better outcomes for patients after trauma. This study represents a critical first step toward better understanding the state of musculoskeletal trauma care in countries with different levels of resources, developing strategies to address deficiencies, and forming regional and international collaborations to develop musculoskeletal trauma care guidelines.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)S64-S70
JournalJournal of orthopaedic trauma
Volume32
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 1 2018
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Wounds and Injuries
Musculoskeletal Development
Guidelines
Education
Postoperative Care
Emergency Medical Services
Poverty
Health Insurance
Rehabilitation
Surveys and Questionnaires
Delivery of Health Care
Physicians
Equipment and Supplies
Mortality
Surgeons

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery
  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

Cite this

Current Status of Musculoskeletal Trauma Care Systems Worldwide. / International Orthopaedic Trauma Study Consortium.

In: Journal of orthopaedic trauma, Vol. 32, 01.10.2018, p. S64-S70.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

International Orthopaedic Trauma Study Consortium. / Current Status of Musculoskeletal Trauma Care Systems Worldwide. In: Journal of orthopaedic trauma. 2018 ; Vol. 32. pp. S64-S70.
@article{5e4903b1dda740d4a8abe18fe7552139,
title = "Current Status of Musculoskeletal Trauma Care Systems Worldwide",
abstract = "BACKGROUND AND RATIONALE: Although general trauma care systems and their effects on mortality reduction have been studied, little is known of the current state of musculoskeletal trauma delivery globally, particularly in low-income (LI) and low middle-income (LMI) countries. The goal of this study is to assess and describe the development and availability of musculoskeletal trauma care delivery worldwide.MATERIALS & METHODS: A questionnaire was developed to evaluate different characteristics of general and musculoskeletal trauma care systems, including general aspects of systems, education, access to care and pre- and posthospital care. Surgical leaders involved with musculoskeletal trauma care were contacted to participate in the survey.RESULTS: Of the 170 surveys sent, 95 were returned for use for the study. Nearly 30 percent of surgeons reported a formalized and coordinated trauma system in their countries. Estimates for the number of surgeons providing musculoskeletal trauma per one million inhabitants varied from 2.6 in LI countries to 58.8 in high-income countries. Worldwide, 15{\%} of those caring for musculoskeletal trauma are fellowship trained. The survey results indicate a lack of implemented musculoskeletal trauma care guidelines across countries, with even high-income countries reporting less than 50{\%} availability in most categories. Seventy-nine percent of the populations from LI countries were estimated to have no form of health care insurance. Formalized emergency medical services were reportedly available in only 33{\%} and 50{\%} of LI and LMI countries, respectively. Surgeons from LI and LMI countries responded that improvements in the availability of equipment (100{\%}), number and locations of trauma-designated hospitals (90{\%}), and physician training programs (88{\%}) were necessary in their countries. The survey also revealed a general lack of resources for postoperative and rehabilitation care, irrespective of the country's income level.CONCLUSION: This study addresses the current state of musculoskeletal trauma care delivery worldwide. These results indicate a greater need for trauma system development and support, from prehospital through posthospital care. Optimization of these systems can lead to better outcomes for patients after trauma. This study represents a critical first step toward better understanding the state of musculoskeletal trauma care in countries with different levels of resources, developing strategies to address deficiencies, and forming regional and international collaborations to develop musculoskeletal trauma care guidelines.",
author = "{International Orthopaedic Trauma Study Consortium} and Theodore Miclau and Paul Hoogervorst and Shearer, {David W.} and {El Naga}, {Ashraf N.} and Zachary Working and Claude Martin and Rodrigo Pes{\'a}ntez and Tobias H{\"u}ttl and Kojima, {Kodi E.} and Michael Sch{\"u}tz",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1097/BOT.0000000000001301",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "32",
pages = "S64--S70",
journal = "Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma",
issn = "0890-5339",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Current Status of Musculoskeletal Trauma Care Systems Worldwide

AU - International Orthopaedic Trauma Study Consortium

AU - Miclau, Theodore

AU - Hoogervorst, Paul

AU - Shearer, David W.

AU - El Naga, Ashraf N.

AU - Working, Zachary

AU - Martin, Claude

AU - Pesántez, Rodrigo

AU - Hüttl, Tobias

AU - Kojima, Kodi E.

AU - Schütz, Michael

PY - 2018/10/1

Y1 - 2018/10/1

N2 - BACKGROUND AND RATIONALE: Although general trauma care systems and their effects on mortality reduction have been studied, little is known of the current state of musculoskeletal trauma delivery globally, particularly in low-income (LI) and low middle-income (LMI) countries. The goal of this study is to assess and describe the development and availability of musculoskeletal trauma care delivery worldwide.MATERIALS & METHODS: A questionnaire was developed to evaluate different characteristics of general and musculoskeletal trauma care systems, including general aspects of systems, education, access to care and pre- and posthospital care. Surgical leaders involved with musculoskeletal trauma care were contacted to participate in the survey.RESULTS: Of the 170 surveys sent, 95 were returned for use for the study. Nearly 30 percent of surgeons reported a formalized and coordinated trauma system in their countries. Estimates for the number of surgeons providing musculoskeletal trauma per one million inhabitants varied from 2.6 in LI countries to 58.8 in high-income countries. Worldwide, 15% of those caring for musculoskeletal trauma are fellowship trained. The survey results indicate a lack of implemented musculoskeletal trauma care guidelines across countries, with even high-income countries reporting less than 50% availability in most categories. Seventy-nine percent of the populations from LI countries were estimated to have no form of health care insurance. Formalized emergency medical services were reportedly available in only 33% and 50% of LI and LMI countries, respectively. Surgeons from LI and LMI countries responded that improvements in the availability of equipment (100%), number and locations of trauma-designated hospitals (90%), and physician training programs (88%) were necessary in their countries. The survey also revealed a general lack of resources for postoperative and rehabilitation care, irrespective of the country's income level.CONCLUSION: This study addresses the current state of musculoskeletal trauma care delivery worldwide. These results indicate a greater need for trauma system development and support, from prehospital through posthospital care. Optimization of these systems can lead to better outcomes for patients after trauma. This study represents a critical first step toward better understanding the state of musculoskeletal trauma care in countries with different levels of resources, developing strategies to address deficiencies, and forming regional and international collaborations to develop musculoskeletal trauma care guidelines.

AB - BACKGROUND AND RATIONALE: Although general trauma care systems and their effects on mortality reduction have been studied, little is known of the current state of musculoskeletal trauma delivery globally, particularly in low-income (LI) and low middle-income (LMI) countries. The goal of this study is to assess and describe the development and availability of musculoskeletal trauma care delivery worldwide.MATERIALS & METHODS: A questionnaire was developed to evaluate different characteristics of general and musculoskeletal trauma care systems, including general aspects of systems, education, access to care and pre- and posthospital care. Surgical leaders involved with musculoskeletal trauma care were contacted to participate in the survey.RESULTS: Of the 170 surveys sent, 95 were returned for use for the study. Nearly 30 percent of surgeons reported a formalized and coordinated trauma system in their countries. Estimates for the number of surgeons providing musculoskeletal trauma per one million inhabitants varied from 2.6 in LI countries to 58.8 in high-income countries. Worldwide, 15% of those caring for musculoskeletal trauma are fellowship trained. The survey results indicate a lack of implemented musculoskeletal trauma care guidelines across countries, with even high-income countries reporting less than 50% availability in most categories. Seventy-nine percent of the populations from LI countries were estimated to have no form of health care insurance. Formalized emergency medical services were reportedly available in only 33% and 50% of LI and LMI countries, respectively. Surgeons from LI and LMI countries responded that improvements in the availability of equipment (100%), number and locations of trauma-designated hospitals (90%), and physician training programs (88%) were necessary in their countries. The survey also revealed a general lack of resources for postoperative and rehabilitation care, irrespective of the country's income level.CONCLUSION: This study addresses the current state of musculoskeletal trauma care delivery worldwide. These results indicate a greater need for trauma system development and support, from prehospital through posthospital care. Optimization of these systems can lead to better outcomes for patients after trauma. This study represents a critical first step toward better understanding the state of musculoskeletal trauma care in countries with different levels of resources, developing strategies to address deficiencies, and forming regional and international collaborations to develop musculoskeletal trauma care guidelines.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85055169399&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85055169399&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/BOT.0000000000001301

DO - 10.1097/BOT.0000000000001301

M3 - Article

VL - 32

SP - S64-S70

JO - Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma

JF - Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma

SN - 0890-5339

ER -