Comparison of fascia iliaca compartment block and 3-in-1 block in adults undergoing knee arthroscopy and meniscal repair

Jerrol B. Wallace, Joseph A. Andrade, Jasen P. Christensen, Lisa Osborne Smith, Joseph E. Pellegrini

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Peripheral nerve blocks have become a popular method for treatment of pain after lower-extremity surgical procedures. Two peripheral nerve blocks for knee arthroscopy include the 3-in-1 block and the fascia iliaca compartment block (FICB). There is limited research comparing the efficacy of these blocks in adults undergoing knee arthroscopy and meniscal repair who receive both the peripheral nerve block and general anesthesia. This was a randomized controlled trial of 60 adult patients undergoing knee arthroscopy under general anesthesia and with a 3-in-1 block or FICB using the same local anesthetic admixture. Onset of block, time to postoperative analgesic requirements, pain scores, and overall satisfaction scores were measured. No differences in analgesic requirements or pain scores were noted. A faster onset of anesthesia occurred in the 3-in-1 block group, but there was a longer duration of postoperative analgesia in the FICB group. Patient satisfaction scores were similar between groups. Based on this study we recommend that the choice of block can be determined by the clinical scenario. We recommend a 3-in-1 block if speed of onset is the primary goal of anesthesia before induction, and we recommend the FICB block if prolonged postoperative analgesia is the primary goal.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalAANA journal
Volume80
Issue numberSUPPL.4
StatePublished - Aug 1 2012
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Fascia
Arthroscopy
Nerve Block
Knee
Peripheral Nerves
Pain
Analgesia
General Anesthesia
Analgesics
Anesthesia
Local Anesthetics
Patient Satisfaction
Lower Extremity
Randomized Controlled Trials
Research
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Fascia iliaca
  • Leg block
  • Lower extremity
  • Regional anesthesia

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine
  • Medical–Surgical
  • Advanced and Specialized Nursing

Cite this

Comparison of fascia iliaca compartment block and 3-in-1 block in adults undergoing knee arthroscopy and meniscal repair. / Wallace, Jerrol B.; Andrade, Joseph A.; Christensen, Jasen P.; Osborne Smith, Lisa; Pellegrini, Joseph E.

In: AANA journal, Vol. 80, No. SUPPL.4, 01.08.2012.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Wallace, Jerrol B. ; Andrade, Joseph A. ; Christensen, Jasen P. ; Osborne Smith, Lisa ; Pellegrini, Joseph E. / Comparison of fascia iliaca compartment block and 3-in-1 block in adults undergoing knee arthroscopy and meniscal repair. In: AANA journal. 2012 ; Vol. 80, No. SUPPL.4.
@article{dd4d6c0ab5c44446a9a76cd6d6e0b02e,
title = "Comparison of fascia iliaca compartment block and 3-in-1 block in adults undergoing knee arthroscopy and meniscal repair",
abstract = "Peripheral nerve blocks have become a popular method for treatment of pain after lower-extremity surgical procedures. Two peripheral nerve blocks for knee arthroscopy include the 3-in-1 block and the fascia iliaca compartment block (FICB). There is limited research comparing the efficacy of these blocks in adults undergoing knee arthroscopy and meniscal repair who receive both the peripheral nerve block and general anesthesia. This was a randomized controlled trial of 60 adult patients undergoing knee arthroscopy under general anesthesia and with a 3-in-1 block or FICB using the same local anesthetic admixture. Onset of block, time to postoperative analgesic requirements, pain scores, and overall satisfaction scores were measured. No differences in analgesic requirements or pain scores were noted. A faster onset of anesthesia occurred in the 3-in-1 block group, but there was a longer duration of postoperative analgesia in the FICB group. Patient satisfaction scores were similar between groups. Based on this study we recommend that the choice of block can be determined by the clinical scenario. We recommend a 3-in-1 block if speed of onset is the primary goal of anesthesia before induction, and we recommend the FICB block if prolonged postoperative analgesia is the primary goal.",
keywords = "Fascia iliaca, Leg block, Lower extremity, Regional anesthesia",
author = "Wallace, {Jerrol B.} and Andrade, {Joseph A.} and Christensen, {Jasen P.} and {Osborne Smith}, Lisa and Pellegrini, {Joseph E.}",
year = "2012",
month = "8",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "80",
journal = "AANA Journal",
issn = "0094-6354",
publisher = "AANA Publishing Inc.",
number = "SUPPL.4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of fascia iliaca compartment block and 3-in-1 block in adults undergoing knee arthroscopy and meniscal repair

AU - Wallace, Jerrol B.

AU - Andrade, Joseph A.

AU - Christensen, Jasen P.

AU - Osborne Smith, Lisa

AU - Pellegrini, Joseph E.

PY - 2012/8/1

Y1 - 2012/8/1

N2 - Peripheral nerve blocks have become a popular method for treatment of pain after lower-extremity surgical procedures. Two peripheral nerve blocks for knee arthroscopy include the 3-in-1 block and the fascia iliaca compartment block (FICB). There is limited research comparing the efficacy of these blocks in adults undergoing knee arthroscopy and meniscal repair who receive both the peripheral nerve block and general anesthesia. This was a randomized controlled trial of 60 adult patients undergoing knee arthroscopy under general anesthesia and with a 3-in-1 block or FICB using the same local anesthetic admixture. Onset of block, time to postoperative analgesic requirements, pain scores, and overall satisfaction scores were measured. No differences in analgesic requirements or pain scores were noted. A faster onset of anesthesia occurred in the 3-in-1 block group, but there was a longer duration of postoperative analgesia in the FICB group. Patient satisfaction scores were similar between groups. Based on this study we recommend that the choice of block can be determined by the clinical scenario. We recommend a 3-in-1 block if speed of onset is the primary goal of anesthesia before induction, and we recommend the FICB block if prolonged postoperative analgesia is the primary goal.

AB - Peripheral nerve blocks have become a popular method for treatment of pain after lower-extremity surgical procedures. Two peripheral nerve blocks for knee arthroscopy include the 3-in-1 block and the fascia iliaca compartment block (FICB). There is limited research comparing the efficacy of these blocks in adults undergoing knee arthroscopy and meniscal repair who receive both the peripheral nerve block and general anesthesia. This was a randomized controlled trial of 60 adult patients undergoing knee arthroscopy under general anesthesia and with a 3-in-1 block or FICB using the same local anesthetic admixture. Onset of block, time to postoperative analgesic requirements, pain scores, and overall satisfaction scores were measured. No differences in analgesic requirements or pain scores were noted. A faster onset of anesthesia occurred in the 3-in-1 block group, but there was a longer duration of postoperative analgesia in the FICB group. Patient satisfaction scores were similar between groups. Based on this study we recommend that the choice of block can be determined by the clinical scenario. We recommend a 3-in-1 block if speed of onset is the primary goal of anesthesia before induction, and we recommend the FICB block if prolonged postoperative analgesia is the primary goal.

KW - Fascia iliaca

KW - Leg block

KW - Lower extremity

KW - Regional anesthesia

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84869407375&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84869407375&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 23248829

AN - SCOPUS:84869407375

VL - 80

JO - AANA Journal

JF - AANA Journal

SN - 0094-6354

IS - SUPPL.4

ER -