A comparison of ordinal analysis techniques in medical resource usage research

David Dilts, Joseph Khamalah

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Ordinal data is prevalent in medical outcomes research; for example, gender, living condition, and use of assistive devices are all both critical explanatory factors in determining the efficacy of medical procedures and are nominal or ordinal data. One basic objective of this study was to compare four assignment (ordinal analysis techniques') prediction of expected patient resource requirements in a specialty ambulatory (outpatient) health care setting. Data from 2427 patient discharges from 7 specialty low vision clinics were collected. Biographical and discharge characteristics of patients were used to develop homogeneous patient groups on the basis of resource use. Resource-use features were then stripped from the data. The four ordinal analysis techniques were subsequently applied to the reduced data set to predict iso-resource group membership for each patient in the data. Chance criterion was used as a benchmark in gauging the predictive ability of each ordinal analysis technique. Prediction results obtained were clinic-specific. This may largely be explained by the fact that the initial iso-resource groups were unique to each clinic and no meaningful iso-resource groups could be obtained from combined data across clinics. No technique was found to be universally superior at all clinics, however, each technique's performance across clinics was consistently better than the benchmark. Contrary to initial expectations, neural networks, in some cases, significantly underperformed the more traditional techniques.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)51-68
Number of pages18
JournalElectronic Notes in Discrete Mathematics
Volume2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 1999
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Resources
Gaging
Health care
Ordinal Data
Neural networks
Benchmark
Nominal or categorical data
Prediction
Healthcare
Efficacy
Assignment
Neural Networks
Predict
Requirements

Keywords

  • Health Care Resource Utilization
  • Ordinal Analysis Techniques

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Discrete Mathematics and Combinatorics
  • Applied Mathematics

Cite this

A comparison of ordinal analysis techniques in medical resource usage research. / Dilts, David; Khamalah, Joseph.

In: Electronic Notes in Discrete Mathematics, Vol. 2, 04.1999, p. 51-68.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{7cabe1dddf5745e495f9515061abd54f,
title = "A comparison of ordinal analysis techniques in medical resource usage research",
abstract = "Ordinal data is prevalent in medical outcomes research; for example, gender, living condition, and use of assistive devices are all both critical explanatory factors in determining the efficacy of medical procedures and are nominal or ordinal data. One basic objective of this study was to compare four assignment (ordinal analysis techniques') prediction of expected patient resource requirements in a specialty ambulatory (outpatient) health care setting. Data from 2427 patient discharges from 7 specialty low vision clinics were collected. Biographical and discharge characteristics of patients were used to develop homogeneous patient groups on the basis of resource use. Resource-use features were then stripped from the data. The four ordinal analysis techniques were subsequently applied to the reduced data set to predict iso-resource group membership for each patient in the data. Chance criterion was used as a benchmark in gauging the predictive ability of each ordinal analysis technique. Prediction results obtained were clinic-specific. This may largely be explained by the fact that the initial iso-resource groups were unique to each clinic and no meaningful iso-resource groups could be obtained from combined data across clinics. No technique was found to be universally superior at all clinics, however, each technique's performance across clinics was consistently better than the benchmark. Contrary to initial expectations, neural networks, in some cases, significantly underperformed the more traditional techniques.",
keywords = "Health Care Resource Utilization, Ordinal Analysis Techniques",
author = "David Dilts and Joseph Khamalah",
year = "1999",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1016/S1571-0653(04)00014-9",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "2",
pages = "51--68",
journal = "Electronic Notes in Discrete Mathematics",
issn = "1571-0653",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A comparison of ordinal analysis techniques in medical resource usage research

AU - Dilts, David

AU - Khamalah, Joseph

PY - 1999/4

Y1 - 1999/4

N2 - Ordinal data is prevalent in medical outcomes research; for example, gender, living condition, and use of assistive devices are all both critical explanatory factors in determining the efficacy of medical procedures and are nominal or ordinal data. One basic objective of this study was to compare four assignment (ordinal analysis techniques') prediction of expected patient resource requirements in a specialty ambulatory (outpatient) health care setting. Data from 2427 patient discharges from 7 specialty low vision clinics were collected. Biographical and discharge characteristics of patients were used to develop homogeneous patient groups on the basis of resource use. Resource-use features were then stripped from the data. The four ordinal analysis techniques were subsequently applied to the reduced data set to predict iso-resource group membership for each patient in the data. Chance criterion was used as a benchmark in gauging the predictive ability of each ordinal analysis technique. Prediction results obtained were clinic-specific. This may largely be explained by the fact that the initial iso-resource groups were unique to each clinic and no meaningful iso-resource groups could be obtained from combined data across clinics. No technique was found to be universally superior at all clinics, however, each technique's performance across clinics was consistently better than the benchmark. Contrary to initial expectations, neural networks, in some cases, significantly underperformed the more traditional techniques.

AB - Ordinal data is prevalent in medical outcomes research; for example, gender, living condition, and use of assistive devices are all both critical explanatory factors in determining the efficacy of medical procedures and are nominal or ordinal data. One basic objective of this study was to compare four assignment (ordinal analysis techniques') prediction of expected patient resource requirements in a specialty ambulatory (outpatient) health care setting. Data from 2427 patient discharges from 7 specialty low vision clinics were collected. Biographical and discharge characteristics of patients were used to develop homogeneous patient groups on the basis of resource use. Resource-use features were then stripped from the data. The four ordinal analysis techniques were subsequently applied to the reduced data set to predict iso-resource group membership for each patient in the data. Chance criterion was used as a benchmark in gauging the predictive ability of each ordinal analysis technique. Prediction results obtained were clinic-specific. This may largely be explained by the fact that the initial iso-resource groups were unique to each clinic and no meaningful iso-resource groups could be obtained from combined data across clinics. No technique was found to be universally superior at all clinics, however, each technique's performance across clinics was consistently better than the benchmark. Contrary to initial expectations, neural networks, in some cases, significantly underperformed the more traditional techniques.

KW - Health Care Resource Utilization

KW - Ordinal Analysis Techniques

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34247354203&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34247354203&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/S1571-0653(04)00014-9

DO - 10.1016/S1571-0653(04)00014-9

M3 - Article

VL - 2

SP - 51

EP - 68

JO - Electronic Notes in Discrete Mathematics

JF - Electronic Notes in Discrete Mathematics

SN - 1571-0653

ER -